Six Minutes Alone: A Knife, a Family, and a Crisis
At 1530 hours you arrive alone at a report of a man with a knife. A 24-year-old male is in the driveway holding a 6-inch kitchen knife and cutting his own forearm, shouting, "Just shoot me." His mother and 14-year-old sister are on the porch about 25 feet away. You are 15 feet from him when you step out, with nothing but your car door for cover. Backup is six minutes out; EMS is staged two blocks away. He stops cutting, turns, and begins walking toward the sister, saying, "I'll do it, I'll do it." Your agency issues a Taser and requires lethal cover before less-lethal deployment.
1. What is your plan for the next six minutes, and what must you not do?
Read the worked answer
Plan:
- Buy distance and cover. Step back behind the engine block or the A-pillar, not the door skin, and use the car as cover while keeping him in view. Put the vehicle between him and you if you can do it without losing sight of the porch.
- Move the family. In a clear, calm voice, direct the mother and sister inside and behind a locked door, or behind the house. They are the most likely victims and the least able to protect themselves.
- One voice. You are the only officer, so you are also the negotiator. Give short, concrete commands: "Drop the knife. Step back. I'm not going to shoot you." Repeat. Avoid a stream of conflicting commands.
- Slow the tempo. Ask about his name, what is going on, whether he is in pain. Time is the resource you have; use it. "Tell me what happened today" does more work than "drop it" alone.
- Update the radio. State the situation, the knife, the family members, your position, and request EMS staged closer with the family inside.
Must not do:
- Close the distance voluntarily on a knife-wielding subject. Fifteen feet is inside the reactionary gap; you cannot out-draw a contact weapon at that range.
- Fire solely to stop self-harm. Deadly force is not justified to prevent a person from injuring himself.
- Deploy the Taser without lethal cover - a Taser that misses or fails against a knife leaves you with an armed subject and nothing behind it.
- Yell at the family to "get down" in a way that pulls their attention and keeps them on the porch.
2. He advances on the sister with the knife raised. Analyze the force decision under Graham, Garner, and North Carolina's justification statutes.
Read the worked answer
The question is not whether he is mentally ill; it is whether he poses an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm.
Graham v. Connor: reasonableness is judged from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene, in the totality, without the benefit of hindsight. The factors: the severity of the threat, whether he is actively resisting or threatening, and whether he is attempting to evade. A man with a knife, fifteen to twenty-five feet from a 14-year-old girl, walking toward her with the blade raised and saying "I'll do it," is an active threat to a third party, not a resisting subject.
Tennessee v. Garner and North Carolina's justification provisions (G.S. 14-51.2 and the force provisions of G.S. 15A-401) permit deadly force to protect against what reasonably appears to be an imminent threat of death or serious physical injury to the officer or another person. That is exactly this fact pattern. Defense of a third party is a distinct and articulate basis from defense of self - and it is the basis you would need here, because he is walking away from you, not toward you.
What you must be able to articulate, one element at a time:
- The knife and its size.
- The distance and closing speed.
- The victim's age and inability to escape.
- His words and conduct immediately before the advance.
- Why no lesser option was available in the seconds you had (and the honest answer may be that less-lethal was not a safe option at that distance without cover).
What does not help you: his mental illness as a justification, or his self-harm as a reason to shoot. Mental illness is part of the totality; it does not lower the threshold, and it does not raise it. The threat to the sister is the whole case.
3. Assume you fire and he goes down. What are your obligations in the next thirty minutes, and what would you say to the family?
Read the worked answer
Immediate:
- Render aid. Cover him, secure the knife, and provide first aid - direct pressure, airway positioning - as soon as it is safe. Request EMS to the scene now, not after the scene is processed. A person you shot is a patient.
- Restore scene control. Handcuff if appropriate, clear the house, keep the mother and sister separated from the driveway and from each other's accounts until someone can take their statements.
- Notify. Supervisor, EMS, and per North Carolina practice the SBI for an officer-involved shooting resulting in death or serious injury, following your agency's protocol. Do not discuss the incident with media or on the radio.
- Preserve. Do not move items, do not walk relatives through the scene, do not handle your weapon beyond securing it as directed by the investigating agency.
Statements. You will give a public-safety statement and later a formal statement under your agency's protocol; compelled administrative statements carry Garrity limits and should be coordinated with counsel. Do not give a casual account to a colleague at the scene.
To the family, say little and say it plainly: "He is hurt and EMS is coming. I need you to stay here with me. Someone will talk with you about what happens next." Do not explain the force decision, do not apologize, do not promise outcomes. Assign an officer to them as soon as one arrives - the mother just watched her son get shot in her driveway, and she is also a witness.
Duty to intervene. If a second officer arrives and continues force after the threat is gone, you are obligated to intervene and report it. That obligation does not end when your slide locks back.