Hail-Storm Door Knock, Gift Card, and Deductible Waiver
After an April hail storm in Greensboro, a public adjuster knocks on the door of a 78-year-old homeowner. The insurer has already inspected and issued a $22,000 check for a roof replacement, which the homeowner has not deposited. The adjuster says the roof is “probably totaled,” asks the homeowner to sign a 20% contingency contract, a direction to pay all insurance proceeds to the adjuster, and an assignment of claim. The adjuster also offers a $500 gift card “for signing today” and says the deductible “can be worked into the bid” so the homeowner pays nothing. The contract is one page and does not mention cancellation rights, the fee on undisputed amounts, or that the adjuster is not the insurer’s representative. The homeowner’s daughter calls the next day and asks to cancel. The adjuster says the contract is binding and the gift card must be returned with a $250 restocking fee.
1. Identify the consumer-protection and contracting violations in the solicitation.
Read the worked answer
Violations. Offering a $500 gift card to induce signing is an illegal inducement/rebate. Saying the deductible can be “worked into the bid” is unlawful because the insured remains responsible for the deductible and the contractor cannot absorb it. A one-page contract missing the cancellation right, the fee on undisputed amounts, the scope of services, and the statement that the adjuster is not the insurer’s representative violates North Carolina public adjuster contracting rules. An assignment of claim and direction to pay all proceeds may also be improper and should not be used to bypass the insured’s control.
2. Is the contract enforceable after the daughter’s cancellation request?
Read the worked answer
Cancellation. The daughter’s call should be treated as a cancellation request; the adjuster should confirm in writing, stop work, and not enforce a restocking fee. The three-business-day cancellation right cannot be waived by a gift card. Even if the contract were otherwise enforceable, the missing disclosures and the inducement taint the agreement. The adjuster should not tell the homeowner that the contract is “binding” without disclosing the cancellation right and providing the required notices.
3. What corrective action should the adjuster take?
Read the worked answer
Return or credit the gift card, provide copies of the contract and cancellation notice, release any assignment/direction to pay, and submit only the homeowner’s existing $22,000 claim information. Do not charge a fee on the undisputed $22,000 or on any amount not produced by the adjuster. The adjuster should send a written cancellation confirmation, stop all claim activity, and document the file. If a fee is claimed for any additional work, it must be reasonable, disclosed, and tied to new recovery.