A Minor, Two Parents, and a Disclosure That Must Be Reported
Your client is 15, four months into treatment for major depression. Her parents divorced two years ago, share joint legal custody, and her mother has primary physical custody; both signed the intake consent. Today she tells you she is "in love" with a 22-year-old coworker, that they have had sex twice, and then shows you healing cuts on her thigh she has hidden from her parents. She begs you not to tell anyone. The age of consent in your jurisdiction is 16. An hour later her mother calls demanding a copy of the entire record and asking what her daughter said in session. Her father calls separately and says he does not consent to any release of information.
1. What are your immediate obligations, and in what order do you handle them?
Read the worked answer
The reporting duty comes first because it is legally mandated and time-bound.
- The relationship is suspected child abuse: she is below the age of consent and the partner is an adult. Report to child protective services (and law enforcement if your jurisdiction requires it). You do not investigate, do not contact the adult, and do not warn him.
- Tell her before you call, in this session, in plain language - what you must report, to whom, and what information you will give. Do not promise silence you cannot keep; if you already implied it, correct it now.
- Assess the self-injury: intent, frequency, method, lethality, whether any episode was suicidal, and a written safety plan. Parental notification of risk is a clinical judgment that usually favors disclosure; the abuse report may require it anyway.
- Document verbatim: her words, what you observed, the report time, the agency and person you spoke with, the report number, and what you told her and her parents.
- Then deal with the records requests, not before.
2. How do you handle the two parents' requests and the limits of a 15-year-old's confidentiality?
Read the worked answer
Verify before you release or refuse - both calls get the same neutral answer.
- Confirm the current custody order in writing; "joint legal custody" commonly means both parents hold rights to records and to consent, but the specifics of the order control.
- Check state law on minor consent: if she consented to her own outpatient mental health treatment under a minor-consent statute, the parents may not have automatic access to those records. This is state-specific and must be checked, not assumed.
- Do not disclose session content on the phone to either parent, and do not let one parent's objection become your decision. Release requires authorization from the parent(s) entitled to it, or a court order.
- Respond to both in writing with the same message: what you need to proceed, and why.
- Tell the daughter what her parents asked and what you did - an alliance destroyed by surprise will cost you the treatment.
- Consult a supervisor or attorney and document the consultation. Do not improvise custody law at the front desk.
3. Six weeks later, the father's attorney serves a subpoena duces tecum for the full record. What do you do?
Read the worked answer
A subpoena is a demand, not an authorization.
- Do not ignore it - ignoring a subpoena exposes you to contempt. Do not simply photocopy the chart either.
- Read it for exactly what is requested and the return date, calendar it, and notify the client's legal guardian(s) so they have time to object.
- Assert privilege on the client's behalf; you do not waive it. Seek a signed authorization, a court order, or a qualified protective order.
- Contact your malpractice insurer or agency counsel immediately; if the family objects, counsel can file a motion to quash or seek a protective order.
- If ordered to produce, release only the minimum necessary, mark it confidential, and keep a copy of everything produced, the subpoena, and all correspondence in the record.
- Consider whether the 15-year-old's own privacy interest should be raised - she is the identified client, and the record contains her sexual history and self-harm.
- Document each step with dates.