Deer Strike on I-94 at Night: First Minute, Legal Duties, and a Live Animal in the Lane
At 11:20 p.m. you are eastbound on I-94 with the cruise set near the 80 mph limit, 40 miles from the next exit, when a deer steps out about 60 feet ahead. You brake hard, but the impact takes out your left headlight and crumples the hood; the car still runs. The deer lands in the left lane. You coast onto the right shoulder and stop with hazards on, wearing a dark jacket and carrying no flashlight. A guardrail runs along your right, so there is no easy way off the shoulder. A semi is closing at about 75 mph in the right lane, and its headlights are already filling your mirror. It is 14 degrees, and there is patchy ice on the shoulder.
1. Describe your first 60 seconds in order of priority. Where do you put yourself, and why?
Read the worked answer
The semi is the immediate threat, not the deer.
In order:
- Keep your seatbelt on, keep the wheels straight, and get the car as far right against the guardrail as it will go. Hazards on, dome light on so you are visible.
- Call 911. Give the direction of travel, the nearest mile marker, and state plainly that a deer carcass is in the left lane. That detail turns your call into a hazard warning for every vehicle behind you and gets a trooper and tow rolling.
- Decide where to be. With a guardrail tight on the right and traffic at 75 mph, the shoulder is not a safe standing area. If you cannot get behind the guardrail, stay belted inside the car with hazards on. A car struck at highway speed is survivable; a person struck is not.
- Do not stand between your car and the traffic lane, and do not walk into a live lane to set flares or triangles.
- At 14 degrees, keep the engine running for heat and confirm the tailpipe is clear of snow and ice.
2. What are your legal and practical duties after the strike - reporting, the carcass, and the arrival of responders?
Read the worked answer
Several duties land at once.
- Report it. A deer collision that disables your vehicle and leaves debris in a travel lane needs to be reported to law enforcement, both for the crash record and for your insurance claim. Stay on the line until the dispatcher releases you.
- Do not drag the deer yourself. It is dead weight on ice, in the dark, in a live lane, and you would be working with traffic passing at 75 mph. Leave it for the trooper or the highway department. An officer can also tell you whether state rules permit salvage of road-killed game; taking it without checking is not a decision to make at 11:20 p.m.
- When the trooper and tow truck arrive with lights on, the Move Over law applies to you as well as to passing traffic: if you are ever driving past a stopped emergency or service vehicle with lights on, move over a lane when possible and slow down substantially when you cannot.
- Do not stop to sightsee, and do not linger after you are released. A secondary crash into the original scene is the most likely crash at this point, and the mirror check matters as much as the work in front of you.
3. As you wait, the deer lifts its head and is still alive in the left lane. What do you do and what do you not do?
Read the worked answer
An injured deer in a travel lane is a live hazard, but it is not yours to handle hands-on.
Do not approach it. A wounded deer can kick with both hind legs and will aim at whatever is close; a hoof strike to the head or chest is a serious injury. Its behavior is unpredictable - it may bolt into traffic or toward you. Handling an injured animal is also outside what you are equipped or authorized to do on an interstate.
Do:
- Call 911 again if you have not, and describe the situation precisely: live animal, left lane, mile marker. Officers are equipped and, in most areas, a trooper or game warden handles dispatch of the animal.
- Keep your hazards on and stay belted in the car if the shoulder is unsafe. If you must be outside, put the car between you and the traffic lane.
- Watch approaching traffic and be ready to move if a vehicle drifts onto the shoulder.
Do not walk into the lane to wave traffic around the animal. A person in dark clothing standing on an interstate at night is effectively invisible until it is too late.