The Lender's Closing, the 30-Day Wait, and the Finished Basement
On April 2, a homeowner calls your desk to buy flood insurance because her mortgage lender requires it. The loan closing is scheduled for April 15. The policy is bound effective April 3 with $250,000 building coverage, $100,000 contents coverage, and a $2,000 deductible. The home is a pre-FIRM single-family dwelling in a Special Flood Hazard Area. On April 28-25 days after the effective date-a river floods the property. The insured reports 3 feet of water in the finished basement. The basement contains drywall, carpet, a furnace, a water heater, a sofa, and a television. The main floor also has 8 inches of water, damaging hardwood floors and kitchen cabinets. The insured asks whether the claim is covered and which basement items will be paid. She also wants to know why the deductible is applied twice.
1. Is the April 28 loss covered given the 30-day waiting period? Explain the lender exception.
Read the worked answer
Coverage is available. The SFIP imposes a 30-day waiting period after the application and payment of premium, so a policy effective April 3 ordinarily would not cover a loss before May 3. The lender-required exception applies when flood insurance is required by a lender in connection with a loan and the policy is purchased at or before loan closing. Here the policy was bound April 3 and the closing is April 15, so the purchase was before closing. The waiting period is waived, and the April 28 loss is within the policy period. The adjuster should document the loan closing date, the lender's requirement, and the policy effective date. If the policy had been purchased after the April 15 closing, the exception would not apply and the claim would be excluded as occurring during the waiting period. The absence of a flood-in-progress issue also supports coverage.
2. Which basement items are covered under the SFIP? Address drywall, carpet, furnace, water heater, sofa, and television.
Read the worked answer
The SFIP covers building elements and utilities in a basement but does not cover finishings or personal property in a basement. The furnace and water heater are building utilities and are covered if they are connected to the building's electrical or plumbing system. Drywall and carpet are finishings; they are not covered in a basement. The sofa and television are personal property in a basement and are not covered. The main-floor damage-hardwood floors and kitchen cabinets-is building damage and is covered, subject to the building limit and deductible. The adjuster should measure the water line, photograph each item, and separate building from contents. If the basement were not a true basement (for example, a walkout with grade on one side), the analysis could change. The insured should be told that the basement limitation is a policy provision, not an adjuster's choice.
3. How should the $2,000 deductible apply to the building and contents payments?
Read the worked answer
The deductible applies separately to building coverage and contents coverage; it is not applied twice to the same coverage. For the building, add the covered main-floor damage and the covered furnace/water heater damage, apply the $250,000 building limit, then subtract one $2,000 deductible. For contents, add only covered contents (not the basement sofa or television), apply the $100,000 contents limit, then subtract one $2,000 deductible. If there are no covered contents, no contents deductible is charged. The insured's question about 'twice' is likely because the policy has separate building and contents deductibles. The adjuster should show the calculation on the estimate and explain that the deductible is per coverage, not per room or per item.