Unsafe drill press and a mismatched grinding disc
A vocational training centre in Ibadan uses a pedestal drill press for 10 mm holes in 6 mm mild steel plate. Trainees report the drill wandering and the chuck getting hot. Checks show 0.18 mm spindle runout at the chuck taper, the table is loose on its column clamp, and the belt guard interlock has been bypassed with a wire. In the same bay is a 230 mm angle grinder rated at 6,600 rpm. The only cutting disc available is marked 80 m/s and 6,500 rpm, with a 22 mm bore, while the grinder spindle is M14 with a 22.2 mm flange. A trainee has fitted the disc without the outer flange and is about to cut a length of 25 mm square bar. The supervisor is away and the centre manager wants the class to finish its assessment pieces today.
1. Diagnose the drill press faults from the symptoms and set out the actions required before any trainee uses it.
Read the worked answer
Wandering and a hot chuck point to excessive spindle runout. The measured 0.18 mm at the chuck taper is far beyond normal machine-tool limits and suggests a bent spindle, worn bearings, a damaged taper or a chuck mounted on dirt or burrs. A loose table clamp adds inaccuracy and is also a crush hazard if the table drops, while the bypassed interlock is a deliberate defeat of a safety device and must be treated as a serious defect.
Actions: lock out and tag out the drill, remove it from service and tell the manager in writing that it is quarantined. Do not let trainees use it. Inspect the spindle taper and chuck with a dial indicator and test bar, check bearings for play and noise, clean and reseat the chuck, and repair or replace worn parts. Restore the interlock to full function and test it; never leave a wire bypass in place. After repair, run a test piece, record runout and table security, and only then return the machine to training. The assessment deadline does not justify using a machine that can injure a trainee.
2. Assess whether the 230 mm disc can be used on the grinder and state what must happen before any cutting starts.
Read the worked answer
The disc is not usable on this grinder. Its maximum speed is 6,500 rpm, below the grinder's 6,600 rpm, so it is over-speed even before the other defects are considered. The 80 m/s marking is a linear rim speed, not a substitute for matching the rpm rating. The missing outer flange is a severe hazard: a cutting disc must be clamped between the correct inner and outer flanges, with the guard fitted and adjusted, or it can burst. The 22 mm bore against a 22.2 mm flange is close but must be checked for proper centring and contact; a loose or wrong flange is unacceptable.
Before any cutting: stop the trainee, isolate the grinder, remove the disc from service, and obtain a 230 mm disc rated at or above 6,600 rpm and suitable for metal cutting. Fit the correct matched flanges, adjust the guard, check the disc for cracks and date, run it up in a safe direction, and require a trained and authorised operator. The trainee should not use a 230 mm grinder unsupervised. PPE includes face shield, eye protection, hearing protection and appropriate clothing; the work should be clamped, not hand-held.
3. The centre manager insists the class finish today. Set out your decision and the controls you would put in place.
Read the worked answer
I would refuse to release the drill press or the overspeed disc, and I would put that refusal in writing to the manager. The hierarchy is clear: eliminate the hazard by removing the equipment from service, then substitute safer methods. For today, trainees can use hand tools or a correctly rated smaller grinder with the right disc, under supervision, and the assessment can be adjusted or rescheduled.
The controls I would apply: lockout and tagging of the drill, quarantine of the disc, a pre-use check sheet for every machine, colour-coded tool tags, and a short briefing to trainees on why the interlock and flanges matter. I would record the manager's instruction and my refusal, and escalate to the centre's safety officer or principal if pressure continues. The legal duty to provide a safe workplace and the duty of care to trainees outweigh a timetable. A burst disc or a dropped table can cause fatal injury, and no assessment piece is worth that risk.