CPD Audit Three Weeks Before Licence Renewal
Dr. Halima Bello is a medical officer in a state hospital in Kano. Her Annual Practising Licence expires on 31 December. On 15 December she has documented 18 CPD points: a hospital grand round (2 points), a five-day national conference (5 points), ten hours of teaching medical students (5 points), and a published case report (6 points). She says she also attended a two-day private workshop in Abuja but lost the certificate, and asks the hospital CPD officer to 'add 12 points' because she is a senior registrar with 12 years' experience. She is on night call on 28 December and has no leave before renewal. The hospital's CPD committee is auditing files. Dr. Bello asks whether she can continue seeing patients in January while she 'sorts it out.'
1. Is Dr. Bello compliant with MDCN CPD requirements? Show how the committee should assess her file.
Read the worked answer
On the documented record, she is short of the MDCN annual CPD requirement, which is 30 points per year under the Council's CPD framework. The committee should verify each claimed activity against the guideline: the grand round, conference, teaching and publication. It should apply any category caps and require certificates or organisers' letters. Her documented total is 18 points, so she is prima facie non-compliant.
The 12 points for the lost workshop cannot simply be added. CPD points must be verifiable; a claim based on memory, seniority or years of experience is not evidence. The committee should ask her to obtain a duplicate certificate or a letter from the workshop organiser. If she cannot, those points should not be credited. The committee should also check that the activities fall within the accepted CPD categories and were completed within the relevant CPD year, not carried over from an earlier period.
Her seniority is not a substitute for points. The audit should be applied consistently to all doctors, and the committee should record its decision and the evidence relied on.
2. What options are open to her before 31 December, and what should the committee advise?
Read the worked answer
She should first try to obtain verifiable evidence for the Abuja workshop - a duplicate certificate, a receipt, the programme and a letter from the organiser. If that fails, she should look for accredited CPD activities that can be completed and certified before 31 December: hospital grand rounds, accredited online modules, a local workshop, or supervised teaching with documented hours. She should not ask anyone to inflate points or backdate attendance; that would turn a CPD shortfall into a dishonesty allegation.
The committee should advise her in writing of her current total, the evidence required and the deadline. If she still cannot reach 30 points, she should not practise after 31 December until her APL is renewed. She should contact the MDCN promptly to ask about late renewal or any remedial process, but she must not assume that an application in progress is a licence. The hospital should arrange cover for her night calls from 1 January if her licence is not renewed.
The safest course is transparency: submit what is verified, complete what can be completed, and cease clinical work if the licence lapses.
3. What are the consequences of seeing patients in January without a valid APL, for her and the hospital?
Read the worked answer
Seeing patients without a valid APL is practising without a licence. That is a regulatory offence and can lead to disciplinary action, including suspension or conditions on practice. It also creates serious medico-legal risk: prescriptions, referrals, death certificates and operative notes signed by an unlicensed doctor may be challenged, and indemnity cover may be refused for an adverse event.
The hospital also carries liability for rostering a doctor whose licence has expired. It should verify licences before the roster is published and should not allow clinical duties to continue merely because renewal is pending. Patient safety is the primary concern; an expired licence is not a clerical inconvenience.
Dr. Bello should inform her clinical director in writing, withdraw from clinical duties from 1 January if the licence is not renewed, and keep evidence of her CPD submissions. If she practises and a patient is harmed, the CPD shortfall will become an aggravating factor rather than a standalone administrative issue.