Housemanship at an Unapproved Hospital with No Consultant Surgeon
Dr. Sani Musa began a one-year housemanship at Sunrise Specialist Hospital, a private 45-bed hospital in Kaduna, in January. The hospital is not approved by MDCN for housemanship. It rotates him through medicine, surgery, obstetrics and gynaecology, and paediatrics, but the consultant surgeon left in June and was not replaced. From July to September Dr. Musa was the only doctor on 12 night shifts and performed 8 caesarean sections and 5 appendicectomies 'under distant supervision' by phone. His logbook has entries signed by the medical director, who is a general practitioner, not a consultant in the relevant specialty. In October the hospital applied retrospectively for approval of its housemanship programme and asked MDCN to credit Dr. Musa's first 8 months so he can sit the full registration examination after 12 months. Dr. Musa has an offer of a medical officer post in Lagos starting in January.
1. Will Dr. Musa's training at Sunrise count toward housemanship? Explain the MDCN requirements for approved centres, rotations and supervision.
Read the worked answer
It should not be credited on the facts given. Housemanship is a supervised training period, not merely twelve months of service. The MDCN requires the training to take place in an approved centre, with the prescribed rotations and supervision by appropriately qualified consultants, and with a logbook that reflects that supervision. Sunrise was not approved when Dr. Musa was appointed, and retrospective approval cannot convert past unsupervised work into approved training.
The supervision was also defective. A general practitioner medical director is not a consultant surgeon or obstetrician, and telephone supervision is not the direct supervision required for a house officer performing caesarean sections and appendicectomies. Those procedures by an unsupervised house officer raise serious patient-safety and competence concerns. The logbook entries do not cure the deficiency because the signatory lacks the relevant specialist standing.
Dr. Musa may need to complete a full or substantially repeated housemanship in an approved centre. The MDCN should assess his actual experience, but it should not award credit simply because he spent eight months at the hospital. The priority is that he receives proper supervision before independent practice.
2. What should MDCN do about the hospital's retrospective application and Dr. Musa's logbook?
Read the worked answer
The MDCN should refuse retrospective approval. Approval of a housemanship centre is prospective and follows inspection of staffing, facilities, supervision and patient load. A hospital cannot apply after the training has occurred and expect the Council to validate it. The application should be treated as a request for future approval only if the hospital can show that it now meets the standards.
The Council should inspect Sunrise, review its staffing and theatre records, and investigate the unsupervised operations. If the hospital misrepresented its supervision or allowed a house officer to operate beyond his competence, that may require regulatory action against the hospital and the responsible practitioners. The logbook should be examined for false or misleading entries; signing off training that was not supervised is itself a serious matter.
Dr. Musa should be treated fairly. If he was placed in an impossible position, his honesty and cooperation should be considered, but his logbook cannot be accepted at face value. The Council should give him written guidance on what would be required to complete approved housemanship.
3. Advise Dr. Musa on his next steps and the risks of accepting the Lagos post.
Read the worked answer
Dr. Musa should not accept a medical officer post that assumes he is fully registered unless and until the MDCN confirms his registration status. He should apply to an approved housemanship centre to complete the required supervised training, disclose his previous experience honestly, and keep copies of all correspondence. He should also write to the MDCN asking for a formal assessment of his training and for guidance on whether any part can be credited; he should not rely on the hospital's retrospective application.
If he starts work in Lagos as a medical officer without full registration and an APL, he would be in the same position as any unregistered practitioner: unlawful practice, disciplinary risk and invalid indemnity. The Lagos employer should be told the truth about his registration status. A short-term job is not worth a registration problem that could follow him for years.
The safest path is to complete approved housemanship, obtain full registration, then apply for an APL. He should also preserve evidence of the supervision failures at Sunrise in case the MDCN or a tribunal needs it.