The 45-Day Reconciliation Gap
Kola is managing director and sponsored individual of a small dealing member with twelve staff. SEC examiners arrive for a routine inspection and find that NGN 62.4 million of client money is sitting in the firm's operating account alongside NGN 18 million of the firm's own funds. No client-money reconciliation has been performed for 45 days. Two clients' contract notes show shares sold, but the proceeds were not credited to their accounts. The firm's board has not met for eight months, the audit committee is dormant, and the external auditor resigned three months ago with no replacement appointed. One client's NGN 9.3 million redemption was paid five days late using an inflow from another client. Kola tells the examiners, 'The finance officer handles reconciliation; I focus on trading.' He also says the firm is 'too small for a full compliance function' and that the auditor left over a fee dispute.
1. Identify the main regulatory breaches revealed by the inspection.
Read the worked answer
The inspection reveals several core breaches. First, client money is not segregated: NGN 62.4 million sits in the firm's operating account with NGN 18 million of firm money. Client assets must be held in designated client accounts and not used for firm purposes. Second, no reconciliation for 45 days breaches the requirement to reconcile client funds and securities regularly and promptly investigate differences. Third, sale proceeds were not credited to clients' accounts, which is a record-keeping and client-asset failure. Fourth, using one client's inflow to pay another client's redemption is a serious misuse of client money and may indicate a shortfall. Fifth, governance failures: the board has not met for eight months, the audit committee is dormant, and the external auditor has resigned with no replacement. That breaches corporate governance and reporting expectations and leaves the firm without audited oversight. Record-keeping is inadequate.
2. What is Kola's personal responsibility as managing director and sponsored individual, and can he defer to the finance officer?
Read the worked answer
Kola cannot defer to the finance officer. As managing director he is responsible for the firm's systems and controls; as sponsored individual he is personally accountable to the SEC for conduct and supervision. Delegation to a finance officer does not transfer regulatory responsibility, especially where red flags - late redemptions, missing reconciliations, a departed auditor - were or should have been visible to him. 'Too small' is not a defence: proportionality may allow outsourced or part-time compliance, but it does not allow no compliance. The fee dispute explanation for the auditor's resignation is not a satisfactory response; a replacement should have been appointed and the SEC notified.
His conduct may amount to failure to supervise, failure to maintain proper records, and possibly knowingly permitting the misuse of client funds. The SEC can take enforcement action against him personally, including suspension or withdrawal of his sponsored-individual registration and disqualification from senior roles.
3. Outline the immediate remediation and the communications with the SEC and affected clients.
Read the worked answer
Immediate remediation: freeze all client-money movements; move client funds into a designated client account; reconstruct the client ledger from bank statements and contract notes; reconcile to the bank and identify any shortfall; stop using new inflows to pay old redemptions; appoint an interim compliance officer and a replacement auditor; convene the board and audit committee; preserve all records. Affected clients should be contacted factually and promptly, told what is being done, and paid what is properly due; the firm should not admit liability beyond established facts, but should not conceal.
The SEC should be notified promptly and given a remediation plan with timelines; early self-report and cooperation may mitigate but do not erase the breaches. A root-cause review should cover segregation, reconciliation, governance and audit. Senior management and the board should be reconstituted as necessary, and disciplinary action taken where warranted. Backdating records or destroying documents would turn a control failure into an enforcement and possibly criminal matter.