An Instagram Post and Divorced Parents
A 16-year-old patient, Elena, comes to a Concord practice for sealants and a cleaning. The hygienist takes intraoral photos with the office tablet for the dentist's chart. After the appointment, she posts a close-up of Elena's upper teeth on her professional Instagram with the caption 'Beautiful transformation! #NHdentalhygiene #sealants' and a smiling emoji. Elena has a distinctive peg lateral and a chipped central incisor; her mother recognizes the teeth and calls the office furious. The parents are divorced; the mother has joint legal custody, the father has physical custody this week. The father later asks for a copy of Elena's complete record, including the photo. The office still uses paper charts, and the hygienist's friend request to Elena on Facebook was accepted last month.
1. Was the Instagram post permissible? What immediate steps are required?
Read the worked answer
No. An intraoral photo is protected health information, and the patient is a minor. Posting it for marketing requires a written authorization that meets HIPAA and New Hampshire requirements, and the parent or guardian must consent. Even without a name, the distinctive peg lateral and chipped incisor make Elena identifiable to her mother and likely others. The caption 'beautiful transformation' adds a clinical claim. Immediate steps: remove the post, preserve a copy of the post and messages for the privacy file, notify the dentist or privacy officer, document who saw it, and apologize without admitting liability. Do not ask Elena to delete her own messages. A Board complaint or HIPAA complaint is possible; the office should not retaliate.
2. How should the office respond to the mother's demand to delete the photo and the father's request for records?
Read the worked answer
Do not delete the original chart or the photo from the record. The photo may be part of the dental record, and altering a record after a complaint is itself a serious problem. Remove the social-media post, but preserve the office copy. For the father's request: verify who has legal authority to request records under the custody order; in many cases either parent with legal custody may access, but the office should follow its policy and legal advice. Provide copies, not originals, with a written disclosure log. Tell the mother the post has been removed and that the office will handle the record request under privacy law. Do not let the parents' dispute force staff to take sides.
3. Elena messages the hygienist privately about a white spot on her gum and asks 'what is it?' How should the hygienist handle the boundary and confidentiality issues?
Read the worked answer
The hygienist should not diagnose or give treatment advice through a personal social-media account. She should reply briefly: 'I can't evaluate that here. Please call the office so a dentist can look at it; if it's urgent, seek care.' Then document the contact in the chart if it relates to care, and tell the dentist. She should consider unfriending or setting boundaries with minor patients; personal accounts should not be used for clinical communication. The boundary issue is not just confidentiality-it is the risk of creating a dual relationship and of giving advice without a record, exam, or consent.