The State Office Building and the Closed Sprinkler Valve
A local fire official in a municipality with a certified local enforcing agency receives an anonymous complaint about a six-story, 120,000-square-foot office building owned by the State of New Jersey and managed by the Treasury. The building is 60 percent occupied by state agencies and 40 percent leased to a private law firm. The caller says the sprinkler control valve in the basement is closed and that boxes are stacked in the exit stair. The fire official arrives at 10:15 a.m. The building manager meets him in the lobby, refuses access, and says, "This is state property; your local ordinance stops at the door. The State inspects us." Through the lobby glass the fire official can see a red tag hanging on a riser pipe and a storage cart in the stair enclosure. The building's sprinkler contractor is scheduled for the annual inspection next month. The fire official has a copy of the current Uniform Fire Code and a cell phone.
1. Who is the authority having jurisdiction for fire code enforcement in this building, and how should the local fire official respond to the manager's claim?
Read the worked answer
The local fire official should not simply accept or reject the manager's claim at the door; the ownership determines jurisdiction. Under the Uniform Fire Safety Act and the Uniform Fire Code, the Bureau of Fire Code Enforcement in the Division of Fire Safety enforces the code in buildings owned by the State of New Jersey. A building owned by the State and managed by the Treasury is a state-owned building even if part of it is leased to a private law firm. The local enforcing agency's jurisdiction generally does not extend to that building. The fire official should document the complaint, the refusal, the red tag, and the storage observed from the lobby, then contact the Bureau of Fire Code Enforcement and provide the information. The fire official should not issue a local penalty or demand entry as if the building were a private commercial property. If the observed conditions present an immediate danger to life, the fire official should say so clearly to the Bureau and to the building manager and request immediate corrective action, but the enforcement file belongs with the Bureau unless the Bureau directs otherwise.
2. The fire official sees a red tag on a riser and a storage cart in the exit stair. What immediate action, if any, is appropriate while jurisdiction is being confirmed?
Read the worked answer
A red tag on a riser is a warning that the system may be impaired, and storage in an exit stair is an egress obstruction. The fire official should not ignore either condition just because the Bureau may be the enforcing agency. The correct approach is to notify the Bureau immediately, describe the conditions, and ask for direction. In the meantime, the fire official can ask the building manager to remove the storage from the stair and to confirm whether the sprinkler system is in service. If the manager refuses and the conditions are life-threatening, the fire official should involve the local fire department's on-duty battalion chief and the police department to address the immediate hazard, while making clear that the enforcement referral is to the Bureau. The fire official should create a written record with times, names, and photographs taken from lawful vantage points. The fire official should not physically force entry or operate the sprinkler valve without authority or an emergency justification.
3. The building's sprinkler contractor is due next month for the annual inspection. What does the contractor owe the authority having jurisdiction if it finds the control valve closed?
Read the worked answer
The contractor's duty is not limited to the building owner. Under NFPA 25 impairment procedures and the contractor's certification obligations under N.J.A.C. 5:74, the contractor must report an impairment to the owner and to the authority having jurisdiction. A closed sprinkler control valve is a critical impairment because it removes water from the system. The contractor should not simply note the condition on a report and leave. It should determine why the valve is closed, whether a proper impairment procedure is in place, and whether a fire watch is required. The contractor should tag the valve, record the condition, and notify the Bureau of Fire Code Enforcement as the AHJ for this state-owned building. If the contractor is a New Jersey certified firm, failure to report a known impairment or falsifying an inspection report can also jeopardize its certification. The local fire official should not be expected to perform the contractor's notification duty, but can reinforce the referral.