The Permit Holder, the Cough Medicine, and the Passenger
At 11:20 p.m., 18-year-old Luis has been on his feet for a 10-hour warehouse shift. He holds a New Jersey motorcycle permit issued three weeks ago and has a valid probationary automobile license. He took 50 mg of diphenhydramine at 9 p.m. for a rash and feels “a little foggy.” A coworker asks for a 2-mile ride home. Luis has a DOT full-face helmet; the coworker has no helmet. The coworker’s house is on a 45 mph road, and Luis’s bike has a working headlight and taillight. Luis rode this route once before, in daylight. He has not had alcohol. He says he feels fine to ride “slow.”
1. List the legal problems with Luis’s plan under New Jersey law.
Read the worked answer
Luis’s motorcycle permit does not allow him to carry a passenger. It also does not allow him to ride after dark; at 11:20 p.m. he is well into the prohibited period. New Jersey requires every operator and passenger to wear a DOT-approved helmet, and the coworker has none. Luis’s probationary automobile license does not expand the motorcycle permit’s limits. The fact that the ride is only 2 miles and that he rode the route once in daylight does not change any of these restrictions. If he rides, he risks a citation and, more importantly, he is operating outside the conditions under which he was tested. The coworker’s lack of a helmet is a separate violation and a serious injury risk.
2. Even without alcohol, why is Luis impaired? How do the medication and fatigue affect his riding?
Read the worked answer
Diphenhydramine is a sedating antihistamine. It commonly causes drowsiness, slowed reaction time, blurred vision, and poor concentration. After a 10-hour shift on his feet, Luis is also physically fatigued, and fatigue multiplies the medication’s effects. “A little foggy” is a warning sign, not a minor detail. New Jersey impaired-driving law is not limited to alcohol; a driver can be charged with driving while impaired by drugs or a combination of drugs and fatigue. Even if Luis’s blood-alcohol level is zero, his ability to brake, swerve, and scan for hazards is reduced. Riding “slow” does not fix delayed reactions or poor balance, and a passenger adds weight and changes the bike’s handling.
3. What should Luis do, and what should he tell the coworker?
Read the worked answer
Luis should not ride, and he should not carry the coworker. He should leave the bike parked, call a ride, take a bus or taxi, or wait until he has slept and the medication has worn off. He should not lend his helmet to the coworker as a way to make the ride “legal,” because he would then be riding without required protection and the permit still bars a passenger and night riding. He should tell the coworker plainly that he is not legal to carry a passenger, that it is after dark, that the medication makes him drowsy, and that neither of them should be on the bike. If the coworker pressures him, Luis should repeat the legal limits and offer to help arrange another ride.