Twelve Officers, Four Thousand People, and $6,200
It is Thursday. You command a 14-officer patrol squad (18 authorized) for Saturday's 1800–0200 shift, and 12 are available. Two officers are on light duty (one fractured wrist, one pregnancy restriction), two called out sick, one is on military leave, and one is at a week-long school. That Saturday the city has a permitted street festival expecting 4,000 people from 1700 to 2200 in a six-block downtown zone; two officers are committed to a 1900 funeral escort; and the detective bureau has asked for two officers to help serve a high-risk search warrant at 2000. Last Saturday the squad handled 82 calls for service in that window, 11 of them priority-one; the district average is 70. The overtime line has $6,200 left with four months to run, and the chief has said no new overtime without his approval.
1. Build a deployment plan for the shift. State your priorities and what you are willing to leave uncovered.
Read the worked answer
Rank by consequence, not by who asked loudest. The order is: life-safety response capability, then the crowd event (a 4,000-person permitted event has the highest potential for a mass-casualty or crowd-crush failure), then fixed commitments, then proactive work, then non-emergency calls.
Sketch. Four officers on festival foot beats 1700–2200, with two of them designated as the redeployable pair - they work the perimeter, not the interior, so they can break away for a priority-one call. Two officers on the funeral escort at 1900; that assignment is short and fixed. Two officers on sector patrol covering the non-downtown geography. One officer on station/report detail and phone follow-ups. You rove as the flex unit and take calls yourself. That leaves roughly three officers to absorb a call load that averaged 82 last Saturday.
What gets left uncovered. Non-emergency and cold calls stack. Set a callback list with dispatch, set the expectation that non-priority calls will be held past 0200, and tell dispatch not to hold units on report calls when a priority-one is pending. Proactive enforcement in the outer sectors stops for the night - that is a deliberate choice, not an oversight.
Brief it. Tell the squad the plan, the reasoning, and their individual assignments at 1745. Officers accept short staffing when they understand the logic; they resent it when it looks arbitrary.
2. How do you handle the detective bureau's request and the funeral escort, and what do you tell the chief about overtime?
Read the worked answer
The funeral escort is a fixed, short commitment the department has already made publicly; it happens, with two officers, 1900–2030 or so.
The warrant is the negotiable item. A high-risk warrant at 2000 on a Saturday night, with a festival six blocks away and 12 officers on the street, is a request that should move. Call the detective sergeant directly and offer three options: postpone to a weekday morning when the full squad is available; run it with detectives plus the on-call tactical element without patrol bodies; or take two patrol officers only if the warrant team supplies its own perimeter. Do not simply refuse - give the bureau a plan. If they insist, escalate the conflict to the patrol captain and let command decide, in writing, whose staffing gets reduced. You are not absorbing a decision that belongs one level up.
The chief. Send a short memo Friday, not Saturday night: the staffing math, the fixed commitments, the projected cost, and two options with numbers. Option A - cover the festival and the warrant with six officers extended four hours each: roughly 24 overtime hours, about $1,550 at time-and-a-half on a $43 hourly base. Option B - festival only, warrant deferred: about 16 hours, roughly $1,030. Note that $6,200 with four months left in the fiscal year is about $1,550 a month, so a single Saturday could consume a month's overtime. Ask for a written decision by Friday 1600 so you are not improvising at 1900.
Never spend the overtime first and explain later.
3. Two officers tell you they will refuse mandatory overtime because "we're always the ones." How do you handle it?
Read the worked answer
Acknowledge the grievance before addressing the order. They may well be right. Pull the last 90 days of overtime assignments and see whether the same four or five names appear. If the distribution is skewed, the fix is a published rotation, not a lecture - and the fastest way to end this conversation permanently is to show them a fair list.
Separate the two issues. The fairness question is a supervisor problem. The refusal to work a directed assignment is a different problem, and it is a serious one: in most departments refusing a lawful direct order during an emergency staffing shortfall is insubordination. Say so calmly and without threat: "I hear the fairness point and I will fix the rotation. Tonight's assignment is an order. If you refuse it, I will document it and it goes up the chain."
Check the contract and the policy before you push. Some CBAs cap mandatory overtime, require notice, or provide for fatigue limits; some require a volunteer call-out first. If the officers are invoking a contractual right, that is not insubordination and your answer changes. Know which one you are dealing with before the confrontation.
Then take the morale issue upstream. Report to the captain that the squad is running short, that overtime is being distributed unevenly, and that fatigue is a safety issue - an officer on a 16-hour day is a liability. Recommend a rotation, a volunteer-first call-out, and comp time where the CBA permits. Document the conversation either way, and follow up with both officers after the shift so the relationship is not left at the refusal.