An Overbroad OPRA Request for Police Records About a Councilman
You are a licensed PI retained by a local blogger. You send an OPRA request to the township police records custodian seeking 'any and all records, including CAD logs, body-worn camera footage, emails, text messages, and internal affairs files, concerning Councilman R.'s noise complaint and alleged domestic dispute at 14 Maple Street on May 4, plus the complete personnel files of every officer who responded.' On the seventh business day the custodian sends a one-line denial: 'Denied - criminal investigatory records and personnel records; request is overbroad.' You believe the public has a right to know because R. voted on the police budget. The blogger wants you to 'get everything' and says he will post it all. You have not yet appealed.
1. Assess the legal strength of the request and the custodian's denial.
Read the worked answer
OPRA requires a request for specifically identifiable government records, not a request for information or research. 'Any and all records' plus emails, texts, internal affairs files, and complete personnel files is classic overbreadth and gives the custodian a strong basis to deny or seek clarification. The criminal investigatory records exemption can cover records generated by law enforcement in a criminal investigation, but it is not a blanket shield for every police record. CAD logs, the incident report, arrest records, and body-worn camera footage may be disclosable in redacted form, depending on the status of the investigation and privacy exemptions. Personnel files are largely exempt, though certain disciplinary records may be accessible. Internal affairs records often fall under separate confidentiality rules. The one-line denial is weak because OPRA requires a written response identifying the exemption and the reasons, but the request itself is broad enough that the custodian may ultimately prevail on much of it.
2. How should you revise the request to improve the chance of production?
Read the worked answer
Narrow the request to specific records tied to the May 4 incident: the CAD incident report, the initial police report, any use-of-force or arrest report, and body-worn camera footage for named responding officers during a defined time window. Drop 'emails, text messages, internal affairs files, and complete personnel files' unless you have a separate, specific basis. Ask for redacted copies and acknowledge that redactions may be necessary. Submit the request in writing to the custodian, cite OPRA, and state the date and incident address precisely. If the investigation is closed, say so and ask the custodian to confirm status; if it is open, ask what records are available without compromising the investigation. A precise request is harder to reject as overbroad and easier for the Government Records Council or a court to review.
3. What are the appeal and enforcement options, and what ethical limits apply to publication?
Read the worked answer
OPRA denials can be challenged by filing a complaint with the Government Records Council or by bringing an action in Superior Court, generally within 45 days. The custodian bears the burden of proving an exemption, but you should first send a written request for the specific exemption and a Vaughn-style index or explanation. A remand or narrowed request often produces records faster than litigation. Ethically, a lawful OPRA request does not authorize publishing unredacted personal information, domestic-disturbance allegations, or material that could defame or harass. You should review records for privacy, victim information, and accuracy before the blogger posts anything. The client's intent to 'post it all' does not override your professional judgment, and you should not use OPRA to obtain criminal history record information or to retaliate against the councilman.