Smoke From the Rear Wheel Well With 18 Aboard
You are driving a 30-foot passenger bus on the right shoulder of a 65 mph highway. There are 18 passengers aboard, including two wheelchair users and three children. You smell burning rubber and see light gray smoke coming from the right rear wheel well. There are no visible flames. The bus is stopped about eight feet from the white line, traffic is passing at highway speed, and the outside temperature is 90°F. One passenger is shouting that the bus is on fire, and another is trying to open the rear emergency door. The fire extinguisher is mounted near the driver's seat. Your cell phone has signal.
1. Do you evacuate immediately? Explain your decision.
Read the worked answer
Yes. Smoke from a wheel well can indicate an overheated brake, a tire fire, or an electrical problem, and any of those can spread quickly. I would treat it as a fire until proven otherwise. I would stop completely, set the parking brake, shift to park or neutral as required, shut off the engine, and take the keys. I would tell passengers in a calm, loud voice to evacuate and to move away from the bus and away from traffic.
The evacuation route matters: I would send them forward and upwind if possible, not toward the rear wheel well, and not into the traffic lane. If the front door is clear, that is the primary exit; if smoke blocks it, use the rear door or windows. I would not wait for flames to appear before evacuating, because a tire fire can produce intense heat and toxic smoke. At the same time, I would not let passengers wander onto the highway; I would direct them to a safe assembly point behind a guardrail or well off the shoulder. The reasoning is that the cost of an unnecessary evacuation is far lower than the cost of a delayed evacuation in a real fire.
2. Give the evacuation sequence for the two wheelchair users and the three children.
Read the worked answer
I would first direct the walking passengers out the front door and away from the smoke, then assign two or three capable adults to help with the wheelchair users. For a manual wheelchair, I would deploy the ramp if it is safe and the chair can be moved quickly; if there is fire near the ramp or the chair cannot be moved, I would use a carry technique with at least four helpers, keeping the chair locked and the passenger belted if possible. I would not use an elevator or lift if it is slow or near the smoke.
For the children, I would keep them with an adult and move them to the same assembly point, away from traffic and upwind. After evacuation, I would count the passengers and account for all 18, including the wheelchair users and children. I would call 911, report the location and the smoke, and tell dispatch. I would not let anyone reboard to retrieve belongings. The reasoning is that a head count is the only reliable way to know whether someone is still aboard, and assigning helpers prevents one person from trying to manage a wheelchair alone during an emergency.
3. When, if ever, would you use the fire extinguisher?
Read the worked answer
I would use the extinguisher only for a small, contained fire and only if I have a clear escape route behind me. I would not go into the wheel well or under the bus to fight a fire, because a tire or brake fire can flare up and the space is confined. If the smoke is coming from an area I cannot safely reach, my job is to evacuate and call the fire department, not to be a firefighter. I would keep the extinguisher available in case the fire blocks an exit or spreads toward the passenger compartment.
The key reasoning is that the extinguisher is a first-aid tool for a small fire, not a substitute for evacuation. If I use it, I would stand with my back to a clear exit, aim at the base of the flames, and abandon the attempt immediately if the smoke increases or the fire does not go out. Passenger safety and a complete head count take priority over saving the vehicle.