The Warehouse Stairway Fall
At 0230, a security guard at a 400,000-square-foot distribution center finds a contractor lying at the bottom of a mezzanine stairway. An aluminum ladder is on its side nearby; the guard sees blood on the floor and a dented hard hat. The contractor is conscious but confused and cannot remember falling. The guard calls his supervisor, takes photos with his phone, and moves the ladder out of the walkway. He does not call 911 because the contractor says he is 'fine.' At 0700, the guard writes: 'Contractor was probably drunk and fell because he was careless. No security issue.' The report omits the time of discovery, the contractor's statements, witness names, lighting conditions, and the fact that the guard moved the ladder. The site's camera system overwrites recordings every 72 hours. The client asks for the report that afternoon.
1. Identify the report deficiencies and write an objective opening narrative for the report.
Read the worked answer
The report fails on several grounds. It contains a conclusion ('probably drunk,' 'careless') not supported by the guard's own observations; it omits the time of discovery, the contractor's confusion, the blood, the dented hard hat, the ladder's position, the guard's decision to move it, witness names, lighting, and the failure to call 911. A useful opening is: 'At 0230 on [date], I was on routine patrol on the mezzanine level when I observed a male contractor lying supine at the bottom of the stairway. An aluminum ladder was on its side approximately 4 feet away. I observed blood on the floor near his head and a dented hard hat. The contractor was conscious but confused and stated he did not remember falling. I called my supervisor at 0232 and did not call 911 because the contractor said he was fine. I moved the ladder out of the walkway at 0235. I did not observe signs of alcohol use.' That is objective, chronological, and separates observation from inference. The guard should also document that he is not a medical provider and whether EMS was ultimately called or declined.
2. What evidence-preservation and scene-management steps should the guard take?
Read the worked answer
The guard should treat the area as an incident scene and preserve evidence. He should request in writing that the client preserve the camera video before the 72-hour overwrite, noting the camera numbers and time range. He should keep his photos in original form, not crop or edit them, and log when they were taken. The ladder should not have been moved unless it blocked rescue or created an immediate hazard; since it was moved, the guard must document exactly where it was and who moved it. Witness names, the contractor's employer, and the contractor's statements should be recorded. The hard hat and any bloodied items should be left for investigators unless the client's safety policy requires cleanup. The guard should notify the client's safety officer and supervisor; in a workplace injury, OSHA reporting may be the employer's duty, but the guard should not assume it has been done. A chain-of-custody form is needed for any item he takes. The report should be completed before the end of shift, not at 0700 after memory fades.
3. What should the guard have done at 0230, before writing the report?
Read the worked answer
At 0230 the priority is the person, not the report. The guard should ensure the scene is safe, check responsiveness and breathing, and not move the contractor unless there is immediate danger. He should call 911 for a head injury with confusion and blood; 'I'm fine' from a confused person is not reliable. He should keep the contractor still, monitor breathing, and send someone for the AED and first-aid kit. He should not give food or drink. He should secure the ladder and area only after medical care is started. If the contractor refuses EMS, the guard should document the refusal in the contractor's words, notify a supervisor, and continue monitoring. The guard should also protect himself from bloodborne pathogens with gloves and eye protection. The later report should include the time 911 was called or the refusal, the contractor's mental status, and who was present. Moving the ladder before photographing its position complicated the investigation; the lesson is to photograph first unless it is an immediate hazard.