Borrowed ID at the Neighborhood Bar
At 8:45 p.m. at a neighborhood bar, a customer orders a draft beer and hands over a horizontal driver's license. The birth date makes the holder 23. The photo resembles the customer, but the license lists a height of 5 feet 8 inches and the customer appears closer to 5 feet 2 inches; the eye color on the license is brown, while the customer's eyes look green. The signature strip is smudged. The customer jokes, 'I look different without my glasses.' The bar is not busy. The customer's friend, who is 22, already has a beer and says, 'He's good, I know him.' The server must decide whether to serve, what additional checks to make, and what to do if the customer admits the ID belongs to a sibling.
1. What discrepancies should the server evaluate, and should the server serve the beer?
Read the worked answer
The server should compare the photo, birth date, height, eye color, signature, and any physical features. The height difference of about six inches and the eye-color mismatch are significant. The smudged signature strip is another warning sign. The customer's joke about glasses does not explain height or eye color. The friend's vouching is not proof of age; friends often cover for each other. On these facts, the server has reason to believe the ID is not the customer's. The server should not serve the beer. The legal question is not whether the customer is 'probably' 21; it is whether the ID reliably proves age, and this one does not.
2. The customer admits the ID belongs to his brother. What should the server do now?
Read the worked answer
Once the customer admits the ID is his brother's, the server should refuse service and ask for the customer's own ID. If the customer has no valid ID, the refusal stands. The server should not confiscate the ID unless house policy and local practice clearly allow it; taking property can escalate. The server should notify the manager or security, document the admission, and ask the customer to leave if he will not accept the refusal. The server should not lecture or humiliate the customer. If the customer is under 21, the establishment may also report the false ID use to law enforcement, depending on policy.
3. What penalties and establishment risks are involved if the server had served the beer?
Read the worked answer
If the server had served the beer, the establishment could face administrative action against its license and the server could face criminal exposure for selling to a minor. The underage customer could be cited for possession or use of false ID. The brother whose ID was used could also face consequences. The establishment's risk increases because the server had clear discrepancies: height, eye color, smudged signature, and a friend vouching. A compliance check or a later investigation would likely treat those facts as notice. The safe course is to refuse and document.