Cash and Truck Title Pledged for a Bond
Roland is licensed and appointed. He writes a $50,000 bail bond for Denise. Denise's mother, Carla, signs as indemnitor. Carla pledges $20,000 cash and the title to a 2018 truck she says is worth $15,000. Roland charges a $7,500 premium based on the rate filed by his surety, plus a $500 'document preparation' fee and a $300 'court appearance' fee. He gives Carla a one-page receipt listing only 'cash and title' and tells her the truck will be 'stored' at his cousin's lot. Denise attends every hearing; the court exonerates the bond. Roland returns $18,000 of the cash and says he will keep the truck title and $2,000 cash for 'storage and file closing.' Carla never received a written collateral agreement or an itemized accounting. She asks for the title and full cash back.
1. Identify the collateral, premium, and fee issues in Roland's handling of this bond.
Read the worked answer
The premium calculation is the least problematic part if $7,500 matches the surety's filed rate for a $50,000 bond and no unlawful deviation occurred. The extra $500 document fee and $300 court-appearance fee are suspect: bail premium is the charge for the bond, and additional charges must be legally authorized, disclosed in writing, and reasonably related to actual services. A court appearance is generally part of the agent's ordinary service, not a separate undisclosed fee.
The collateral handling is worse. Carla pledged $35,000 in value, but the receipt says only 'cash and title.' It does not identify the vehicle, state its agreed value, explain storage, insurance, redemption, or return conditions, or authorize a storage fee. Using the agent's cousin's lot creates a self-dealing conflict. Retaining the title and $2,000 after exoneration without an itemized accounting is inconsistent with fiduciary handling of collateral.
2. What records and written disclosures should have existed, and what should Roland produce now?
Read the worked answer
Roland should have maintained a written collateral agreement identifying each item, its owner, agreed value, location, insurance, and the conditions for return. He should have given Carla a receipt for each item and kept a ledger showing premium, fees, collateral, and disbursements. Any fee beyond premium should have been disclosed in a signed agreement before the bond was posted and should be traceable to an actual cost.
Now he should produce the bond application, signed premium and fee disclosures, collateral agreement, receipts, trust-account ledger, storage invoices, and an itemized accounting. If he cannot produce a signed authorization for the $500, $300, or $2,000 charges, he should not retain them. He should also disclose the cousin's relationship and provide proof of the vehicle's condition and location. Missing records should be reconstructed accurately, not fabricated.
3. How should the $20,000 cash and truck title be accounted for after exoneration, assuming no unpaid premium or actual costs?
Read the worked answer
After exoneration, the surety's risk has ended, so the collateral must be returned. Assuming the $7,500 premium was already paid or separately earned and there are no documented unpaid lawful charges, Roland should return the full $20,000 cash and the truck title. He cannot keep $2,000 for 'file closing' or storage unless Carla signed a valid agreement authorizing that specific charge and the charge reflects an actual cost.
The correct process is a written accounting: beginning collateral, any lawful deductions with supporting receipts, and ending balance returned to Carla. If the truck was stored, Roland must show the agreed storage terms and actual invoices; a generic 'storage' label is not enough. If he already withheld $2,000, he should return it unless he can document a lawful, disclosed obligation. Carla may file a complaint with the Division of Insurance if the accounting is refused.