The Blue Liquid, the Credo Blade, and the 1099
You have worked six months at a small neighborhood salon. The owner sets your hours (10 to 7, Tuesday through Saturday), sets the service menu prices, provides all products and implements, and hands you the schedule of clients she booked. She has just asked you to sign a 1099 as an independent contractor. She also tells you to "just soak the files and buffers in the blue liquid and reuse them - nobody checks," and a walk-in client is asking you to dig out an ingrown toenail with a credo blade because "the last girl did it." The shop's appearance-enhancement license is framed at the register; your own nail specialty license is in a drawer at home.
1. How do you respond to the ingrown toenail request, and what is the boundary you are working from?
Read the worked answer
Refuse, and explain the boundary without diagnosing. A nail specialty license covers manicuring, pedicuring, and nail enhancement - cosmetic services on the visible nail plate and surrounding skin. An ingrown toenail is a medical condition involving living tissue, possible infection, and in some clients a circulatory risk; cutting into it is outside your scope, and New York prohibits razor-type implements and credo blades in appearance-enhancement establishments in any case.
The reasoning to give the client: "I'm not licensed to treat that, and using that tool could make it worse or cause an infection." Then offer what you can do - soak, gently cleanse, no digging, no aggressive corner work - and refer her to a podiatrist. Document the refusal and the referral. If the owner pressures you to do it anyway, that is a scope-of-practice instruction you cannot follow; the license and the liability are yours.
2. The owner insists the files can be reused after soaking. Explain what is wrong with that instruction and how you would answer her.
Read the worked answer
Files, buffers, and porous abrasives are porous: disinfectant cannot penetrate the surface the way it penetrates the matrix of a metal implement, and organic dust and debris in the grit inactivate the disinfectant itself. Soaking them in a jar also turns the jar into a contaminated reservoir that every subsequent file passes through. The correct handling is single-use: use it on one client, then discard it or give it to that client in a labeled envelope. Non-porous implements (nippers, pushers, metal bits) get cleaned with detergent, rinsed, dried, then fully immersed in an EPA-registered hospital-grade disinfectant for the label contact time.
Answering the owner: this is not a preference, it is a requirement, and the person who gets cited and sued is the one holding the license. Offer the practical alternative - buy files in bulk so the cost per client is pennies, build it into the service price, and keep a labeled container at each station for used items. If she still refuses, the risk is yours; the honest move is to stop performing services there rather than sign off on a practice you know is unsafe.
3. What is wrong with the licensing and the 1099 arrangement, and what would you do about both?
Read the worked answer
Licensing: the shop's appearance-enhancement license and your individual nail specialty license are separate credentials, and both need to be in order and available at the work location you are practicing in. A license in a drawer at home is not posted, and you are the one who is practicing unlicensed if you cannot produce it. Bring it in and display it; make sure the shop license is current.
Classification: the label on the tax form does not decide the status - the working relationship does. The owner sets your hours, sets your prices, supplies your tools and product, and provides the clients. That is control, and control points toward employee. Signing a 1099 does not change it; it shifts payroll tax and workers' compensation exposure onto you while she keeps the control of an employer, and it can leave you without injury coverage when you are the one handling nippers and chemicals all day.
The judgment: ask for the arrangement to match reality, keep your own copies of schedules and pay records, and get advice before signing. Do not sign a document you believe is inaccurate just because you need the hours.