Three Signs, One Curb Space, Forty-Five Minutes
It is 9:15 a.m. on a Tuesday in Queens. You want to leave your car for 45 minutes while you visit a dentist. The curb space you find has three signs on two poles. The first pole holds "NO STANDING 7 AM-7 PM MON-FRI" with an arrow pointing left. The second pole holds "NO PARKING 8 AM-6 PM SAT" with an arrow pointing right, and directly beneath it "STREET CLEANING 9 AM-10:30 AM TUES & FRI." A fire hydrant sits about 12 feet in front of your front bumper. The car parked in the space ahead of you has no ticket on it, and a delivery van is idling in the traffic lane behind you.
1. Can you leave the car in that space for 45 minutes right now? Identify every restriction that applies.
Read the worked answer
No. At least three separate rules block it:
- Street cleaning, 9-10:30 AM Tuesday. You arrive at 9:15, squarely inside the window, so the space is closed for cleaning.
- No Standing, 7 AM-7 PM Monday-Friday. It is a Tuesday at 9:15, so this applies to the curb side indicated by the left-pointing arrow.
- The fire hydrant 12 feet ahead. Stopping or parking within 15 feet of a hydrant is prohibited regardless of what any sign says, and 12 feet is inside that zone.
The fact that the car ahead has no ticket proves nothing; enforcement is intermittent, and in any case a ticket-free neighbor is not a legal opinion. Any one of these three would be enough to make the space unavailable.
2. What do "No Standing" and "No Parking" actually permit, and could you at least stop to let a passenger out here?
Read the worked answer
The two signs are not the same restriction:
- No Parking means you may stop temporarily to load or unload passengers or merchandise, but you may not park and wait.
- No Standing is stricter: you may stop only long enough to pick up or drop off a passenger, not to load goods and not to wait.
So on a street posted only "No Parking," a quick drop-off is generally fine. Here the curb is posted "No Standing" during the hours in question, which narrows you further.
But the hydrant controls the outcome. Because the space is within 15 feet of a hydrant, no stopping, standing, or parking is permitted there, which rules out even the brief passenger drop-off. The signs and the hydrant stack, and the hydrant alone is decisive. The trap is reading the sign cluster, deciding the drop-off is fine under No Standing rules, and ignoring the hydrant.
3. Suppose you come back Saturday at 7:00 p.m. Which restrictions have lapsed, and can you park here then?
Read the worked answer
By Saturday evening most of the signs have expired:
- No Standing, Mon-Fri 7 AM-7 PM: does not apply on Saturday at all.
- No Parking, Sat 8 AM-6 PM: expired at 6:00 p.m.
- Street cleaning, Tue & Fri: not Saturday.
So a driver who reads only the signs concludes the space is legal. It is not. The fire hydrant is 12 feet from your front bumper, and the 15-foot hydrant rule is a standing law that no schedule ever turns off. Your vehicle would sit within that zone.
The useful habit is to treat sign schedules as one layer and fixed distance rules as another. Sign times expire; hydrant, crosswalk, corner, and driveway clearances do not. This particular space is never legal for you, no matter what day or hour you return.