Bus Stop, Hydrant, and the School Bus
At 7:42 a.m. on a Tuesday, you are assigned to a commercial block near a school. A white cargo van with commercial plates is stopped in a signed bus stop. The sign reads 'NO STANDING 7 AM-10 AM EXCEPT SUNDAY.' The van's driver is not in the vehicle; you can see him about 30 feet away at a coffee cart. The van's front bumper is 6 feet from a fire hydrant. Alternate-side parking (ASP) is posted for 8:00-9:30 a.m. on that block, and it is not a holiday. A school bus is approaching with its yellow lights flashing. The van's rear bumper does not block a crosswalk or driveway. You have a citation book and a measuring tape. Your supervisor has told the squad to prioritize obstructions that affect school buses and emergency equipment. You have about four minutes before the school bus reaches the stop.
1. Identify every violation that is active at 7:42 a.m. and explain which posted restriction is not yet active.
Read the worked answer
Active at 7:42 a.m.: (1) the bus-stop restriction, because the sign prohibits standing 7-10 a.m. and the van is unattended; (2) the hydrant restriction, because the van is parked (the driver is out of the vehicle and 30 feet away) with its front bumper 6 feet from the hydrant, and the rule is no parking within 10 feet. Not active: ASP, which begins at 8:00 a.m.; the van is not blocking a crosswalk or driveway. The key distinction is that standing can include a driver who remains with the vehicle, but here the driver is absent, so the vehicle is parked. The hydrant measurement should be taken from the closest point of the vehicle to the hydrant, not from the curb.
2. What enforcement action should you take first, and what facts should you record? Explain your reasoning.
Read the worked answer
First priority is the bus stop because a school bus with flashing yellow lights is approaching and the van blocks the loading area. The hydrant is also a safety issue, but the immediate operational need is to clear the bus stop. I would direct the driver to move the van if he returns promptly; if not, I would begin the citation process for the bus-stop violation and record the hydrant distance. Facts to record: time, exact location, sign text, vehicle plate and state, driver status, distance to hydrant, school bus presence, and whether the van moved. If department policy allows multiple summonses for separate violations, I would document both; if not, I would cite the violation that most directly caused the obstruction and note the other in my activity log. The reasoning is to solve the safety problem first while preserving an accurate record.
3. The driver returns and says, 'I was only gone for two minutes; the hydrant rule is 15 feet.' How do you respond and what do you do?
Read the worked answer
I would not argue about the 15-foot claim. I would calmly state that the rule enforced on this block is no parking within 10 feet of a hydrant, and that his front bumper measured 6 feet from it. I would ask him to move the van out of the bus stop immediately. If he moves it, I would still document the observation and the warning; whether a citation is issued depends on policy and whether the violation was completed. If he refuses, I would issue the citation and note his statement in the record. The reasoning is that the measurement is objective, the safety issue is urgent, and the record should show both the rule applied and the driver's response.