Elevator Outage and a Rider Who Wants to Use the Stairs
At 9:10 a.m., a rider using a motorized wheelchair arrives at an accessible station and finds the street-to-mezzanine elevator out of service. The mezzanine-to-platform elevator is working. The rider needs the downtown platform to attend a medical appointment in 35 minutes. The nearest accessible station is three stops away, but the elevators there are also reported out on the agency's alert page. A station attendant is available, and a supervisor is 15 minutes away. The rider refuses to wait and says, 'Just help me down the stairs; I've done it before.' The stairway has 24 steps and no handrail on one side. You have a radio, the elevator outage hotline, and a list of accessible nearby bus routes. The station has no wheelchair lift or evacuation chair. The rider is becoming upset and other passengers are watching.
1. What do you say and do first when the rider asks you to help him down the stairs?
Read the worked answer
I would not help him down the stairs by holding or carrying the wheelchair. That is unsafe for both of us and is not an approved way to provide access. I would say: 'I can't safely take you down those stairs. I'm going to get you a verified accessible route.' I would keep him in a safe waiting area away from the stair edge, radio the supervisor, and call the elevator outage hotline to confirm which nearby elevators and buses are actually working. I would offer the station attendant as an escort if one can be spared without leaving the booth unattended. Why: the refusal is about safety, not refusing service. The agent must show that an alternative is being arranged, not just say no.
2. What accessible alternatives can you offer, and how do you decide which is reasonable given the 35-minute appointment?
Read the worked answer
Options: an accessible bus route from the station to the destination or to a station with a verified working elevator; Access-A-Ride or an accessible taxi arranged through the supervisor; or a different subway route only after confirming the destination and transfer elevators are working. The alert page says the nearest accessible station's elevators are out, so I would not send him there without a live confirmation. Decision rule: the alternative must be confirmed accessible, have a realistic travel time for the appointment, and not require an unsafe transfer. If no option fits 35 minutes, I would say so honestly, arrange the fastest confirmed option, and ask the supervisor to help with a documented alternative. I would not promise a time I cannot verify.
3. How do you document and escalate, and what should the record avoid?
Read the worked answer
Document time, elevator ID and outage, rider's destination need ('medical appointment in 35 minutes'), the request to use the stairs, the refusal and why, alternatives offered, rider's response, supervisor and hotline notification, and any escort or transportation arranged. Escalate to the supervisor immediately and to the station's ADA/operations contact if no accessible option is confirmed. Avoid unnecessary medical detail, opinions about the rider's attitude, guarantees ('you will make your appointment'), and fault conclusions. Use neutral facts: 'Rider stated he needed the downtown platform by 9:45; street elevator out; north bus route confirmed accessible at 9:25.' Why: the record should show that the agency offered a safe alternative and should not create a promise or a privacy problem.