Investment Strategy and Prudent Person Standard
You are the trustee of the Greenfield Trust, which has a portfolio of $5 million. The trust deed allows investments in a wide range of assets but requires the trustee to act as a prudent person would. The beneficiaries are the settlor's widow, aged 75, who receives $50,000 per year from the trust for living expenses, and the settlor's two grandchildren, aged 10 and 12, who will receive the capital when they turn 25. The current portfolio is 80% in growth assets (shares and property) and 20% in fixed income. The widow has asked for an increase in her annual distribution to $80,000 to cover rising medical costs. The grandchildren's parents have requested that the trust invest more conservatively to protect the capital for the grandchildren. The trustee is considering changing the investment strategy to 50% growth and 50% fixed income to reduce risk. The trust's annual income from the portfolio is currently $150,000.
1. Analyse the trustee's investment duties and how they apply to this situation.
Read the worked answer
The trustee has a duty to invest prudently, considering the interests of all beneficiaries and the purpose of the trust. Under the prudent person standard, the trustee must consider: (1) the risk of loss and the need to preserve capital; (2) the likely income return and the need for liquidity to meet distributions; (3) the need for diversification; (4) the terms of the trust deed; (5) the beneficiaries' circumstances. Here, the widow relies on the trust for income, while the grandchildren are entitled to capital in the future. The trustee must balance the widow's need for higher income against the grandchildren's interest in capital preservation. A move to 50% fixed income may reduce risk but also reduce long-term growth, potentially harming the grandchildren. The trustee should consider a total return approach, where income and capital growth are both considered. The trustee should also consider the impact of inflation on the widow's fixed distribution and whether a higher distribution is sustainable. The trustee must act impartially and not favor one beneficiary over another. The trustee should review the investment strategy regularly and document the rationale.
2. What factors should the trustee consider when deciding whether to increase the widow's distribution to $80,000?
Read the worked answer
The trustee must consider: (1) the trust deed's terms regarding distributions to the widow; (2) the widow's reasonable needs, including medical costs; (3) the impact on the trust's capital and future income; (4) the interests of the grandchildren as remainder beneficiaries; (5) the sustainability of the increased distribution given the portfolio's income of $150,000; (6) whether the increase can be funded from income or requires capital encroachment; (7) the trustee's duty of impartiality. If the distribution is increased, the trustee should consider whether the investment strategy needs to change to generate more income, but without taking excessive risk. The trustee should also consider whether the widow has other resources. The decision should be documented, and the trustee should communicate with all beneficiaries. If the trustee cannot balance the interests, they may need to seek court directions.