The Council's Request
A community kapa haka group has been invited to perform at a city council's multicultural festival. The council has offered a 15-minute slot and asked the group to open with a 'short, friendly welcome' and to 'leave out the haka because it might intimidate some audiences.' The group's set normally includes a haka as the final item. The haka includes a pukana (facial expression) and a strong foot stamp. The group has 12 performers, including two rangatahi who are new to the group. The council liaison says other cultural groups are doing shortened performances and that the festival is about 'bringing communities together.' The group's tutor is unhappy but doesn't want to lose the invitation. The group meets to decide how to respond.
1. Explain the tension between the council's request and the group's cultural practice.
Read the worked answer
The council wants a 'friendly' welcome and asks the group to leave out the haka because it might 'intimidate' audiences. The group's haka is a central part of its set and includes pukana and foot stamps, which are normal elements of haka and not intended as aggression. The tension is between making Māori performance palatable to a non-Māori audience and maintaining the integrity of the art form. Haka is not simply a performance; it can be a welcome, a challenge, or a statement of identity. Removing it changes the meaning of the set. The council's request also assumes that haka is inherently aggressive, which is a misconception. The group has to decide whether to educate the council, compromise, or decline. The presence of new rangatahi also matters because the group is modelling how to handle these situations.
2. Recommend how the group should respond, including what they might offer the council.
Read the worked answer
The group should respond respectfully but clearly. They could explain that haka is not about intimidation and that it is an important part of their set. They could offer to provide a short spoken introduction to explain the haka to the audience, or they could perform a different item, such as a waiata ā-ringa, as a welcome, while keeping the haka in the set. If the council insists on no haka, the group should consider whether performing at all is consistent with their values. They might negotiate a longer slot or a different format. It is important not to simply comply without discussion, because that would set a precedent that haka can be removed for comfort. The group could also ask the council to consult with Māori staff or advisors. The recommendation should protect the group's mana while leaving room for dialogue.