The Ancestor's Haka
A kapa haka group from a tertiary institution has been invited to compete at a regional festival. They have learned a haka composed by a famous ancestor of one of the group's tutors. The haka is known as a haka tapu, traditionally performed only by descendants of the ancestor and only on certain occasions. Two members of the group are descendants, but the other 18 are not. The tutor says the haka is 'too good not to perform' and that the group has learned it well. A kaumātua from the local marae advises that performing it at a competition without the consent of the descendant whānau could be seen as disrespectful. The group has four weeks until the festival. They must decide whether to perform the haka.
1. Explain the significance of haka tapu and why the group's decision matters.
Read the worked answer
Haka tapu is a haka that is set apart, often restricted to descendants or specific occasions. It is not just a performance; it carries whakapapa, mana, and spiritual significance. Performing it without consent can be seen as violating the relationship between the haka and the ancestor's descendants. It matters because the group is not solely the two descendants; the other 18 members do not have the whakapapa connection. The kaumātua's advice points to the risk of disrespect. The group's decision also affects the tutor, who may have a personal connection. If the group performs the haka at a competition, it could be judged by people who know its history, and the group's reputation could suffer. The issue is about ownership and consent, not just skill.
2. Recommend a decision and outline the steps the group should take.
Read the worked answer
The group should not perform the haka tapu at the competition without the consent of the descendant whānau. Steps: first, the tutor and the two descendants should identify the appropriate whānau representatives and seek a meeting. Second, they should explain the context and ask for permission, or ask for guidance on whether the haka can be performed. Third, if permission is granted, the group should follow any conditions (e.g., acknowledgements, restrictions on filming). If permission is not granted, the group should choose another haka from their own repertoire and prepare it in the four weeks. The tutor's view that the haka is 'too good not to perform' should be balanced against the risk of causing harm. The group could also ask the kaumātua to help select a replacement.