The 35-Year Driveway and the Prescriptive Easement Letter
A surveyor is asked to survey a 2.1-acre parcel, Lot 22 in a 1950s subdivision. The deed describes the lot by lot and block per the recorded plat. The owner has used a gravel driveway that crosses about 0.15 acre of Lot 23, the adjoining lot, for 35 years. The neighbor recently had a survey that shows the driveway entirely on Lot 23 and has demanded removal. The owner asks the surveyor to prepare a survey showing the driveway as part of Lot 22 and to write a letter stating that the owner has a prescriptive easement. The owner also has a 1978 unrecorded deed that describes the driveway as an appurtenance. The surveyor finds no written easement in the chain of title.
1. Can the surveyor comply with the owner's request? Explain the professional and legal limits.
Read the worked answer
The surveyor cannot show the driveway as part of Lot 22 or certify a prescriptive easement. A surveyor locates and depicts physical evidence, monuments, and lines of occupation; a prescriptive easement is a legal interest created by a court's application of law to facts. The owner's 35 years of use may be relevant to the statutory period, and the use must generally be open, notorious, adverse, and continuous, but whether those elements are met is a legal conclusion. The 1978 unrecorded deed may be evidence, but it is not in the chain of title and its effect is a title question. The surveyor should show the record Lot 22/Lot 23 boundary and the driveway as a line of occupation or claim, note the absence of a recorded easement, and advise the owner to consult an attorney.
2. What evidence should the surveyor gather and how should it be shown on the survey?
Read the worked answer
Gather dates and descriptions of driveway use, maintenance, repairs, gates, fences, and any interruptions. Look for aerial photos, tax records, utility records, and witness statements that establish when the driveway appeared. Locate the driveway limits and centerline, the Lot 22/Lot 23 boundary, and any monuments found. Show the driveway as 'apparent driveway/line of occupation' and add a note that the survey does not determine title or an easement. If the 1978 unrecorded deed is provided, identify it as an unrecorded document outside the chain of title. The survey should make clear what is record boundary, what is physical occupation, and what is claimed.
3. What if the owner insists on a letter for the neighbor stating that a prescriptive easement exists?
Read the worked answer
The surveyor may provide a factual letter describing what was observed and measured, such as the driveway location, the Lot 23 crossing, visible age indicators, and the absence of a recorded easement. The letter should expressly state that it is not a legal opinion and does not determine title or easement rights. The surveyor should not write that a prescriptive easement exists. If the owner needs a legal position, the owner should retain counsel. If the owner pressures the surveyor to sign a false or misleading survey or letter, the surveyor should decline the work.