Withholding a Contact Lens Prescription to Protect Dispensing Sales
Dr. Nguyen fitted a 29-year-old patient with toric soft contact lenses 11 months ago. The fitting was uncomplicated and the patient has worn the lenses without redness or decreased vision. The patient now asks for a copy of the contact lens prescription so she can order lenses online. The office manager says the practice releases contact lens prescriptions only after the patient purchases a six-month supply from the office. The patient’s chart lists an expiration date of 24 months from the fitting date, although Dr. Nguyen cannot recall discussing a two-year duration with her. The patient submits a written request and says she cannot afford the office supply price.
1. Must the practice release the contact lens prescription? Can it condition release on purchasing lenses from the office?
Read the worked answer
Yes, the prescription must be released. A contact lens prescription is the patient’s prescription, and the practice cannot withhold it to protect dispensing revenue. Conditioning release on an office purchase is an improper tying arrangement and interferes with the patient’s ability to comparison shop. The patient made a written request and is within the stated prescription period, so the staff should provide a complete copy promptly. A reasonable copying or verification fee may be permitted, but it cannot be used as a de facto purchase requirement. The office manager’s policy is the kind of business practice that generates Board complaints and can support discipline for unprofessional conduct.
2. The chart says the prescription expires 24 months after fitting. How should Dr. Nguyen handle that entry?
Read the worked answer
Dr. Nguyen should verify the prescription rather than let staff rely on a chart entry she cannot substantiate. If she clinically intended a shorter duration, she should correct the record and issue an accurate prescription. A blanket office policy cannot extend a prescription beyond the period the prescriber actually authorized. At 11 months the patient is within even a one-year period, so the immediate release obligation is clear. If the prescription had expired, the patient would need a new examination before lenses could be dispensed, but the practice still could not refuse to release an expired prescription or use expiration as a sales tactic. The accurate date matters because online sellers and patients rely on it.
3. What should the practice do when an online seller contacts it to verify the prescription?
Read the worked answer
The practice should respond to a legitimate verification request within the required timeframe and confirm only the prescription information, not the patient’s entire record. It should not ignore the request, impose purchase conditions, or tell the seller that verification is unavailable unless the patient buys from the office. Staff should use a written verification log and route clinical questions to Dr. Nguyen. If the prescription is valid, the seller may fill it. If the practice believes the prescription is invalid or the patient needs a new fitting, it should state the clinical basis and offer an appointment. Refusing to verify without a legitimate reason can violate contact lens prescription release and verification rules and is a business practice the Board may review.