Three Doubles, a Muscle Relaxer, and a Regular
10:40 p.m. A 38-year-old woman has been at the bar for about 90 minutes. The bartender on the earlier shift poured her three vodka-sodas as doubles, and a group at the end of the bar bought her a shot around 10:15. She is flushed across the cheeks and neck, is talking noticeably louder than the room, and her speech is slightly thick - she says "shtrawberry" when ordering a strawberry lemonade for her friend. Reaching for her purse, she knocks a glass off the bar and laughs it off. When she stands to wave at someone, she is steady on her feet and polite. She mentions she started a new prescription two days ago: "a muscle relaxer, but I'm used to it." At 10:42 she slides her card across the bar and orders a fourth double. Her friend, who has had one beer, says, "She's fine, she's a regular, she's always like this."
1. Apply the "noticeably intoxicated" standard to this guest. Do you pour the fourth double, and which specific observations drive your answer?
Read the worked answer
Do not pour it. The legal test is not "falling down" or "unconscious" - it is whether a reasonable person can observe signs of impairment. She has several at once: flushed skin, thickened speech, volume and mood change, and a loss of fine motor coordination when she knocked the glass over. Layer on the consumption pattern: three doubles plus a shot in 90 minutes is roughly seven standard drinks, which for most adults produces impairment well before visible symptoms appear, so the visible symptoms mean she is further along than she looks. The muscle relaxer is a genuine aggravating factor - she is combining a central nervous system depressant with alcohol, and you do not need to diagnose the interaction to recognize added risk. Being polite and standing steadily does not cancel slurred speech. Refuse the fourth drink, take the card off the bar so it is not sitting there inviting a re-order, and tell the manager.
2. She insists she is fine and the friend vouches for her. How do you handle the refusal and what do you offer instead?
Read the worked answer
Acknowledge her without debating her: "I'm not going to pour another one for you tonight - you've had a fair amount and you're slurring a little, and that's my call to make." Do not argue about whether she is intoxicated, and do not let the friend's vouching change the decision; friends routinely underestimate impairment and sometimes have an interest in keeping the evening going. Do not accept the card, and do not sell her a drink "to sip." Offer water, coffee, and food, and offer to call a ride or hold her tab open for a soda. If she presses or becomes angry, hand it to the manager so the refusal comes from a second voice. Watch the friend's ordering too - a sober companion ordering a drink and passing it over is still a service to an intoxicated person. Document the refusal time, the drink count, and the specific observations in the incident log.
3. What do you document and hand off at shift change - and what do you do if she tells you she drove herself?
Read the worked answer
Write down the time, the number and type of drinks, the specific cues (slurred speech, flushed skin, spilled glass, the medication comment), the fact that service was refused, who was notified, and whether she left or stayed. Hand it verbally to the incoming bartender and note the table in the POS so nobody reopens her tab with alcohol. If she drove herself, that changes the risk profile: impairment plus a car keys situation is exactly how a dram shop claim starts. Offer to call a rideshare, offer to park her car for the night, and ask for the keys - you can ask, you cannot forcibly take them. If she insists on driving and is clearly impaired, call police and describe the situation; a welfare call that ends with a sober ride home is far cheaper for everyone than a crash, an injury, and an ABLE investigation into your service.