One Policy Year, Three Claims, and a Home Bakery Nobody Underwrote
The Hendersons own a 22-year-old house in Edmond, Oklahoma, insured on an HO-3 with a $450,000 Coverage A limit, a $2,000 all-perils deductible, and a 2% windstorm/hail deductible. Three events hit in one policy year. In June, hail destroys the roof; the adjuster sets replacement cost at $28,000 with $9,000 of depreciation. In August, a fire caused by the commercial double-decker oven Mrs. Henderson uses in her state-licensed home bakery chars the kitchen, causing $22,000 of damage, and a customer picking up an order slips on the porch and claims $30,000 in medical bills and lost wages. In October, a burglar steals her inherited jewelry collection, valued at $12,000. The bakery grosses $64,000 a year and is not mentioned anywhere on the policy.
1. Compute the hail claim payment, including what is paid initially and what is paid later, and identify what the homeowner ultimately absorbs.
Read the worked answer
The windstorm/hail deductible is a percentage of the Coverage A limit, not of the loss: 2% × $450,000 = $9,000.
Replacement cost: $28,000. Depreciation: $9,000. Actual cash value: $19,000.
Initial payment: $19,000 ACV − $9,000 deductible = $10,000.
Recoverable depreciation: released when repairs are completed and invoiced - $9,000.
Total net recovery: $28,000 − $9,000 deductible = $19,000. The homeowner absorbs the $9,000 deductible (plus any upgrades and unmatched shingle costs).
Two traps to flag. First, the flat $2,000 all-perils deductible does not also apply - a single occurrence carries a single deductible, and the higher wind/hail deductible governs. Second, the wind/hail deductible is a fixed dollar amount tied to the dwelling limit; it does not shrink because the loss is modest, so a $12,000 hail claim on this house would pay only $3,000. The gap between the $10,000 first check and the roofer's invoice is the most common source of complaints in this claim, so explain the depreciation process before the work starts.
2. Analyze the $22,000 oven fire and the $30,000 slip-and-fall under the HO-3, and state what the Hendersons actually need.
Read the worked answer
Both are business-pursuit losses and both fail.
- The oven fire: business personal property used in a business is excluded. Homeowners forms typically allow only a small sublimit - commonly around $2,500 - for business property on the residence premises, and often nothing at all for business stock or property used in a service business. Even if the sublimit applies, $2,500 against $22,000 is a rounding error.
- The slip-and-fall: the liability section excludes bodily injury arising out of an insured's business pursuits. A state-licensed bakery grossing $64,000 a year, with customers coming to the door, is a business by any definition - continuous, regular, for money. The claim is not covered; the customer's recourse is the Hendersons personally.
What they need: a commercial general liability policy for the bakery (premises and products-completed operations), commercial property or inland marine for the oven and equipment, and business income coverage. If they insist on keeping the exposure in the homeowners policy, the narrower tool is a home-business endorsement or business-pursuits endorsement - but read the eligibility: it usually will not cover a food business with retail customers or the products-completed-operations exposure. The engagement, not the transaction: document the coverage declination in the file.
3. Determine the jewelry theft recovery and recommend the correct fix.
Read the worked answer
Recovery is likely zero, and that is not the insurer being difficult.
Homeowners forms impose a special sublimit on theft of jewelry, watches, and furs - commonly $1,500 to $2,500 in the base form. Assume $1,500 here. The $2,000 all-perils deductible then applies to that sublimit, so nothing is payable: the deductible exceeds the available limit. Even with a $500 deductible the payment would be $1,000 on a $12,000 loss.
Recommended fix: a scheduled personal property endorsement (valuable articles floater) listing the jewelry with an appraisal or bill of sale. Key features to explain to the client:
- No deductible and, more importantly, no special sublimit - each item is insured for its scheduled amount.
- Broader perils, typically all-risk including mysterious disappearance - a stone that falls out of a setting is a covered loss, which is not true under the homeowners form.
- Separate limit, so a large jewelry loss does not consume the Coverage C limit.
- Re-appraise every 2–3 years; scheduled items are paid at the scheduled amount, so an old appraisal becomes its own underinsurance problem.
Inherited collections often arrive with no appraisal at all, which is why the loss in this fact pattern was uninsurable after the fact.