Late-Notice Fire Claim With Missing Inventory Records
On March 3, a fire damages the rear warehouse of a small furniture importer. The insured, K&L Imports, reports the claim on April 17-45 days later-after its landlord asks for repairs. The policy requires prompt notice, a signed sworn proof of loss within 60 days of request, and examination under oath. The insured's public adjuster submits a $410,000 estimate, including $90,000 for inventory that the insured says was in the warehouse but has no purchase invoices for. The fire marshal has not determined a cause; there is evidence a back door was propped open and a prior insurance claim for a similar fire at another location. The public adjuster demands payment within 10 days and threatens to report the insurer for bad faith. The adjuster's supervisor says, "Just deny it for late notice and be done." The policy limit is $500,000; the deductible is $10,000.
1. Should the adjuster deny solely for late notice? Explain the analysis.
Read the worked answer
No. A 45-day delay is a coverage issue to investigate, not an automatic denial. The adjuster should determine what the insurer lost because of the delay: were the scene, the inventory, or the fire evidence altered? Did the insured's delay prevent a cause-and-origin investigation? The file should show specific prejudice or explain why the delay does not defeat coverage. Even in a jurisdiction or policy where late notice can bar a claim, a blanket denial without a prejudice analysis and without addressing the other coverage issues is risky under Oregon's unfair claim settlement practices rules. The adjuster should send a written reservation of rights, keep investigating, and tell the public adjuster that the demand for payment in 10 days does not override the policy's proof-of-loss and examination provisions. The supervisor's instruction should be documented and escalated if it would result in a premature denial.
2. Outline the next steps the adjuster should take, including proof of loss, examination under oath, and communication with the public adjuster.
Read the worked answer
The adjuster should acknowledge the claim, request a signed sworn proof of loss with supporting documentation, and schedule examinations under oath for the persons with knowledge of the inventory and fire. The adjuster should obtain the fire marshal's report, preserve the scene and any video, review the prior similar claim, and inspect the back door evidence. The public adjuster should receive a written explanation of the outstanding information and a reasonable deadline, not a refusal to communicate. The adjuster should issue a reservation-of-rights letter identifying late notice, inventory documentation, and possible arson or fraud as issues, while making clear that no final coverage decision has been made. The adjuster should also consider referring the file to special investigations and should document every contact. Payment should not be made on the inventory portion until the documentation is verified.
3. What are the risks of paying the $90,000 inventory portion without invoices, and how should the adjuster respond?
Read the worked answer
Paying without invoices or other records creates a serious risk of overpayment and fraud. Inventory is easily overstated after a fire, and the missing purchase records are a major verification gap. The adjuster should request purchase orders, bank statements, tax returns, inventory software reports, supplier statements, and photos of the warehouse contents. The examination under oath should explore how the inventory was tracked and why no invoices exist. If the records still do not support the claimed amount, the adjuster should deny or reduce that portion with a written explanation tied to the policy's duties and the proof-of-loss requirement, rather than denying the entire claim. The building damage and other verified portions should be handled separately so the insured is not left without payment for clearly covered items. The file should document the fraud indicators and the basis for whatever inventory payment is made.