Sponsorship, Student Data, and an FBLA Shortfall
The FBLA chapter at Roosevelt High has 45 members and a $1,200 annual budget, with $600 currently unrestricted. Twenty-two students qualified for state conference, where registration is $85 per student plus $25 for transportation and $20 for meals. A local car dealership offers $2,000 to cover most of the shortfall if the chapter displays the dealership's logo on all chapter materials, posts three promotional videos featuring students, and provides the dealership with a list of members' names, email addresses, and grade levels. The officers are enthusiastic. A separate group wants to hold a car wash on a school day during marketing class, arguing it is authentic learning. The principal will approve the car wash only if it does not disrupt instruction, and district policy requires parent permission for release of student directory information. Two qualifying students cannot afford the $130 total cost and have not told anyone; the adviser learned this from a counselor.
1. Analyze the dealership's sponsorship offer and write a counterproposal that protects students and the chapter.
Read the worked answer
The cost is $130 per student, so 22 students need $2,860. With $600 available, the chapter faces a $2,260 gap. The $2,000 offer is attractive, but the conditions go beyond ordinary sponsorship. Providing names, emails, and grade levels to a business for marketing is a student-data issue even if some directory information is normally releasable; district policy requires permission here, and grade levels plus emails are especially sensitive. Requiring three videos featuring students also needs media releases, and requiring all chapter materials to carry the logo could imply school endorsement.
Counterproposal: the dealership may be recognized as a conference sponsor on a banner, in the chapter's social media posts written by the adviser, and at a chapter meeting. No student directory information will be shared. Only students with signed media releases may appear in optional promotional videos, and no student will be required to promote the dealership. The donation goes to the chapter, not to individual students, and is disclosed to families. If the dealership insists on student data or mandatory student promotion, decline the money. Not every shortfall should be closed with strings attached.
2. Recommend how to close the remaining gap and support the two students without singling them out.
Read the worked answer
After the $2,000 sponsorship, $260 remains. That is exactly the cost for two students, but the adviser should not announce that two students are poor. Instead, create a general conference-assistance application open to any qualifier, with the counselor handling eligibility privately. Use a chapter scholarship fund, alumni contributions, or a short opt-in fundraiser to cover the gap. A digital coupon book or a business-sponsored social media campaign can raise $300 without using class time.
If the car wash is approved as a Saturday event, direct its net proceeds to the assistance fund. Keep the process confidential: students submit a simple request, the counselor verifies need, and the adviser receives only a yes or no. Do not require students to publicize their family's finances or perform extra work for the subsidy. The goal is full participation, not charity theater. Also build a small reserve for next year so the chapter is not dependent on one sponsor.
3. The officers want a car wash during marketing class. Decide whether to approve it and explain how it could still meet marketing standards.
Read the worked answer
A car wash during marketing class is a poor default because it displaces instruction, creates supervision and insurance questions, and may use school water and facilities without approval. The principal's condition is clear: no disruption to instruction. So the in-class version should not be approved as proposed.
Approve a Saturday car wash only with a facilities request, adult supervision, and a written safety plan. Or keep the project in class as a campaign for a nonprofit or school event, with students doing the market analysis, pricing, promotion, and post-event evaluation. If the car wash proceeds, make it a real project: calculate supplies at $60, set a $8 price, find the break-even point at 8 cars, design a promotion plan, and track actual results. Students should present what worked and what did not. That meets marketing standards without pretending that a class-period fundraiser is automatically authentic learning.