Fifteen Yards and Twenty Phones
At 22:10 on a Friday, Agent Boone is on foot patrol in a strip-mall lot under contract with the property owner. Near a pizza shop he sees two men, 15 yards away, arguing over a parking space. One, wearing a hooded sweatshirt, draws a black semi-automatic pistol and presses the muzzle against the other man's chest. Roughly 20 people are standing outside the pizza shop, some filming on phones. Cars are moving along the fire lane behind the men. Boone carries a 9mm with two spare magazines and is Act 235 certified; he is not a police officer. He has a radio and a can of OC. His partner is 200 feet away on the other side of the building.
1. Is deadly force legally available to Boone here? State the test and the specific facts he must be able to articulate afterward.
Read the worked answer
The test. Pennsylvania's justification provisions in Chapter 5 of the Crimes Code treat defense of a third person the same way they treat self-defense: deadly force is available only when the actor reasonably believes it is immediately necessary to prevent death or serious bodily injury to the person defended, and the defender must not be the initial aggressor.
Why this is close to the paradigm case. A muzzle pressed against a man's chest is an imminent threat of death. Boone is not required to wait for the shot, and he is not required to retreat from a place he has a right to be.
But justification on paper is not the whole answer. If Boone fires he must be able to articulate, in specific, observed terms:
- Identification - that the man he shot was the aggressor and not a bystander, a responding officer, or the victim who had disarmed the other man. Hooded sweatshirts at 15 yards in the dark have caused fatal misidentifications.
- Immediacy - what he saw in that second that told him the trigger was about to be pulled.
- Necessity - that no lesser option was available in the time he had.
- Backstop - that the rounds he fired, and any he missed, would not travel into the 20 bystanders or the moving fire lane behind the men.
The honest answer: the legal authority likely exists, but the field of fire is bad, and a justified shot that kills a bystander in the pizza line is still a catastrophe. Legality and soundness are two different questions here, and the exam wants both.
2. Given the crowd and the fire lane, what lesser options exist, and in what order should Boone work them?
Read the worked answer
Work from least to most, fastest to slowest, and buy time:
- Cover and angle. Move off the line of the pistol toward a parked car or a pillar. Do not close directly. Change the geometry so the pizza-shop wall and the parked cars become the backstop instead of the crowd.
- Voice. Loud, short, unambiguous: "Security - drop the gun." Announce once, clearly. Do not scream a speech. The crowd's phones are already recording; the command should sound like a professional giving an order, not panic.
- Move the crowd. Point at the nearest bystanders and tell them to get inside, in plain words. Reducing the crowd reduces the risk of every round fired.
- Partner and radio. Call the partner and dispatch simultaneously with a description, location, and the fact of a firearm.
Why not OC first? OC at 15 yards with any wind, against a man already holding a gun, is a low-probability hit that announces Boone's intention and may accelerate the shooting. Intermediate force against a deadly threat is not a required step; it is only useful when it is likely to work.
Discipline point: the decision to fire is made in the moment, but everything Boone does in the first three seconds shapes whether he has to. Cover, geometry, and voice are force-avoidance tools, not courtesies.
3. Boone fires or holds, and police arrive to find a man in a security uniform standing over a body with a pistol in his hands. What must he do?
Read the worked answer
He is a suspect until proven otherwise. Responding officers have no way to distinguish him from the second shooter, and the fastest way to be shot is to turn toward arriving police with a gun in his hand.
- If he has fired or is holding the man at gunpoint: as soon as directed, holster slowly or lay the weapon on the ground and step back, hands visible and empty. Do not bend down to place it gently - a motion toward the ground reads as reaching. Follow every command exactly, including being handcuffed and disarmed.
- Identify, briefly, in third person: "I'm private security, Act 235, my name is Boone, the gun is mine, on the ground here, the man with the knife is that one." Short sentences. No explaining the law on the pavement.
- Point out the scene: weapon, witnesses, phones, and that the cameras at the pizza shop exist.
- Do not debate, do not resist, do not wander. Any dispute is settled later with a lawyer and a written statement.
Reporting after: request medical treatment if injured, and give a statement only after the initial identification - then obtain representation before giving a full recounting. Consistency of the first short account with the later detailed one matters enormously. A "rough" recollection given at the scene and contradicted by video destroys credibility.