After the shaking stops: a tsunami decision on the north coast
At 10:12 a.m. a magnitude 7.9 earthquake ruptures offshore, about 80 km north of a coastal village. Shaking lasts 90 seconds and cracks a concrete water tank. Fifteen minutes later the sea draws back about 100 m, exposing the reef. Some people walk out with baskets to collect fish. The village has no tsunami siren; one battery radio works; the nearest safe high ground is a ridge 2 km inland, about 25 minutes' walk. The school on the hill is 3 km away. A tide table shows low tide at 1:00 p.m. One elder says, 'The earthquake was far away under the sea, so there will be no wave.' Another says, 'The sea always goes out before low tide.' The radio reports no official warning yet, and some people are waiting for one.
1. Is the sea retreat a tsunami warning sign? Use evidence about the earthquake, the timing and the tide table to justify your decision.
Read the worked answer
Yes. The retreat is a strong natural warning. A magnitude 7.9 shallow offshore earthquake is exactly the type that can displace the sea floor and generate a tsunami. Shaking lasted 90 seconds, which indicates a large rupture, and 80 km is close enough to be a near-field source: waves can arrive within about 10 to 30 minutes.
The sea drew back 100 m at about 10:27, only 15 minutes after the quake. Low tide is not until 1:00 p.m., and normal tides change gradually, not by 100 m in minutes. The retreat is the trough of a tsunami wave arriving; the first wave may not be the largest. Waiting for an official warning is dangerous because near-field waves can arrive before any warning. The elder's reasoning is wrong: an offshore source close to the coast is more dangerous, not less.
2. Recommend what the village should do in the next 30 minutes. Explain why returning to the reef after 20 minutes would still be unsafe.
Read the worked answer
Everyone should move immediately to the ridge, on foot, without waiting for a siren or official warning. Take the radio, water and a first-aid kit; help elderly people and people with disabilities; avoid river mouths, bridges and roads that run along the shore. The ridge is 2 km away and about 25 minutes' walk, which is within the likely arrival time only if people leave at once. The school hill is farther, so the ridge is the better choice.
Returning after 20 minutes is unsafe because tsunamis arrive as a series of waves, often 10 to 30 minutes apart, and later waves can be larger than the first. The water can also surge like a fast river and carry debris. There is no all-clear until authorities say so; the village should stay on high ground for several hours.
3. Explain why this earthquake gives the village little warning time, and suggest two practical ways to improve future safety.
Read the worked answer
The earthquake is close to the coast, so the tsunami is near-field. In deep water a tsunami travels at about 200 m/s, so 80 km could take roughly 7 minutes, and shallow coastal water slows it further. The official warning system may not reach a village with no siren and one radio in time. The earthquake shaking itself is the warning.
Practical improvements:
- Education and drills: teach everyone that long or strong shaking, or the sea drawing back, means move uphill immediately without waiting.
- Marked evacuation routes and signs: identify the ridge route, keep it clear, and store a radio and supplies there.
A community radio protocol and a simple siren would help, but they must support, not replace, the natural-warning rule.