Sole Breadwinner with Group Cover, a Large Mortgage, and No Disability Protection
Ramon Dizon, 38, is a plant supervisor and the family's only full-time earner. His basic salary is PHP 1.5 million; with 13th-month pay and allowances, total annual compensation is PHP 1.8 million. His wife earns about PHP 240,000 a year from part-time tutorial work. They have three children aged 4, 7 and 10, and a 15-year mortgage with PHP 4.2 million outstanding at 7.5%. The employer provides group life equal to two times basic salary and an HMO with a PHP 150,000 maximum benefit per illness; there is no critical illness cover, no disability income, and no personal accident policy. Savings are PHP 350,000. His 71-year-old father depends on him for PHP 20,000 a month of medical support. The couple has no will and no mortgage redemption insurance. Ramon smokes and has borderline hypertension; his last full medical examination was three years ago.
1. Estimate Ramon's life insurance need on stated assumptions and break down the gap.
Read the worked answer
The method matters more than the final number, so state each assumption.
Needs. (1) Income replacement: 70% of PHP 1.8 million = PHP 1.26 million a year for 10 years, discounted at 5%, an annuity factor of about 7.72, giving roughly PHP 9.7 million. (2) Mortgage: PHP 4.2 million, because the family must keep the house. (3) Education: about PHP 3.0 million for three children at today's costs escalated to age 18. (4) Father's support: PHP 240,000 a year for five years, present value about PHP 1.05 million. (5) Final expenses and estate settlement: PHP 0.5 million. Total need is about PHP 18.5 million.
Resources. Group life of two times basic salary = PHP 3.0 million, plus PHP 350,000 savings = PHP 3.35 million. Wife's income is not counted as a death benefit, and the house is illiquid.
Gap. Roughly PHP 15 million. Two adjustments: group life ends when employment ends and is not portable, and the projection assumes the wife's earnings continue at PHP 240,000. If the family would rather self-insure part of the education cost, the gap falls; if they want 15 years of income replacement, it rises by about PHP 5 million. Present the range, not a single figure.
2. Prioritise the recommendations and explain why the HMO and group life are not substitutes for personal cover.
Read the worked answer
Priority order. (1) Build the emergency fund to six months of expenses; at roughly PHP 110,000 a month, that is about PHP 660,000 against PHP 350,000 today, funded before new premiums. (2) Protect the income with pure term life of about PHP 15 million, level or decreasing to match the mortgage, with a disability income rider or a separate policy. (3) Upgrade health cover and add critical illness cover. (4) Add mortgage redemption insurance assigned to the lender. (5) Execute a will and check beneficiary designations.
Why existing cover fails. The HMO's PHP 150,000 maximum benefit per illness is exhausted quickly by cancer, dialysis, or a cardiac procedure, and it pays hospital charges, not the household's living costs during treatment. Group life at two times basic salary is PHP 3.0 million against a PHP 15 million need, and it terminates on resignation or retirement, exactly when cover is hardest to buy.
Silent risk. At 38, the probability of a period of disability before age 60 is higher than death, and no policy covers it. A disability would stop the PHP 1.8 million income while the mortgage and tuition continue. Address this before any investment product is discussed.
3. What underwriting and implementation issues must be resolved before he applies?
Read the worked answer
Underwriting. Smoking plus borderline hypertension will trigger a medical examination, and possibly a rated premium, an exclusion, or a decline at standard rates. Disclose both fully: non-disclosure gives the insurer grounds to rescind, which is the worst outcome for a family relying on the policy. Consider applying to more than one insurer to compare offers, and never pay a premium before the policy is issued.
Sum assured and limits. Non-medical limits mean a PHP 15 million sum will require full medicals and financial justification; the 13th-month pay and allowances support the income declaration, so prepare an employment certificate and ITR.
Sequencing. Do not cancel or replace anything until the new policy is in force; there is no existing personal cover to replace here, but the principle holds.
Documentation. Choose revocable or irrevocable beneficiary designation deliberately, name contingent beneficiaries, and align the designation with the will so the proceeds are not dragged into the estate. For the mortgage, use a proper assignment so the lender is paid first and the balance goes to the family. Keep protection premiums within about 5% to 8% of income; if the full sum is unaffordable, buy term now and add later rather than buying a small whole-life policy.