Chained Exit and Faulty Fire Alarm in a Multi-Tenant Factory
A five-storey flatted factory in San Po Kong houses 180 workers in 12 tenant units. The building has one 1.2 m wide staircase serving all floors. On inspection you find the ground-floor exit door chained and padlocked, with a sign saying 'Keep closed against theft'; 200 L of flammable solvent in 20 L drums stored in the ground-floor corridor; and the fire alarm control panel showing three faults that have been logged for 21 days. The last fire drill was 14 months ago and only 40 workers took part. A tenant says the staircase is also used to store cardboard because the goods lift is often out of order. The landlord says the corridor storage is the tenants' responsibility. A fire safety improvement notice was issued eight months ago but no follow-up inspection has been recorded. The factory manager asks you to 'write something reasonable' for the insurer.
1. What are your immediate actions and in what order? Explain your priorities.
Read the worked answer
Priority 1 - means of escape: remove the chain and padlock immediately and keep the exit usable. A locked exit in a single-staircase building can turn a small fire into a multiple-fatality event. Clear the staircase and corridor of cardboard and solvent drums; move the solvent to a properly ventilated store with spill containment, or remove it from the building.
Priority 2 - alarm and detection: treat the three faults as a serious deficiency. Arrange urgent repair by a competent contractor, and in the meantime institute a temporary fire patrol with a documented round and a means of raising the alarm. Do not accept the panel as 'monitored' unless it is continuously monitored.
Priority 3 - notify and secure: inform the landlord, all tenants and the factory manager in writing. Record the condition with photographs and a timeline. If the exit cannot be made safe immediately, consider restricting occupancy of the affected floors and notify the Fire Services Department.
Reasoning: life safety comes before documentation and insurance. The single staircase means there is no alternative escape route, so the exit and the staircase must be kept clear and unlocked at all times. The solvent adds a rapid-fire hazard, and the alarm faults remove early warning. The previous improvement notice makes the failure more serious, not less.
2. Design an evacuation plan and drill programme that addresses the single staircase and the 12 tenants.
Read the worked answer
Evacuation strategy: total evacuation on alarm, because a single staircase gives no reliable defend-in-place option. Appoint a building fire coordinator and a floor warden for each floor, with deputies. Tenants must nominate wardens and provide after-hours contact details.
Assembly and roll call: designate an assembly point at least 30 m from the building, clear of the fire service access. Each tenant keeps a current staff list and reports missing persons to the coordinator. Include contractors, visitors and disabled workers in the plan, with personal emergency evacuation plans and a refuge area if the staircase cannot be used.
Signage and equipment: escape route signs, emergency lighting, fire extinguishers and a working alarm. Keep the staircase and exit door unobstructed and unlocked. Display the plan in each unit and in the lobby.
Drills: at least twice a year, with at least one unannounced drill; vary the time to include night shifts. Record date, participants, evacuation time, problems and actions. The last drill had only 40 of 180 workers, so require tenant participation and follow up absent units.
Reasoning: a plan that exists only on paper fails when the alarm sounds. Drills test the single-staircase assumption, warden communication and roll call, and they reveal blocked exits before a real fire does.
3. Allocate responsibilities among the landlord, tenants and your role, and specify the records needed for the insurer and the regulator.
Read the worked answer
Landlord: maintain the common parts, staircase, exit doors, fire alarm panel and emergency lighting; ensure the building complies with the fire safety improvement notice; coordinate repairs and provide a safe means of escape. The landlord cannot disclaim responsibility for the corridor by saying it is the tenants' storage.
Tenants: keep their units and the common areas clear; store solvents in approved containers and areas; train staff; participate in drills; report faults and damage.
Your role: inspect, record, advise and escalate. Do not write an insurer's report that says the building is satisfactory when the exit is chained. State the facts, the risk and the required actions with deadlines.
Records: inspection reports and photographs; improvement notice and follow-up correspondence; alarm fault log and repair certificates; solvent storage inventory and safety data sheets; drill records; warden appointments; training records; maintenance records for exits, lighting and alarm; minutes of tenant meetings. Keep them dated and attributable.
Reasoning: the insurer and the regulator need evidence of a functioning management system, not reassurance. Clear allocation prevents the landlord and tenants from blaming each other while the exit remains locked. Accurate records also show that you escalated the risk, which is important if an incident occurs.