Policy Replacement and Ethics
Agent Smith is meeting with a 65-year-old client, Mrs. Jones, who owns a whole life policy with a $250,000 death benefit and $50,000 cash value. The policy was purchased 20 years ago and has a current annual premium of $3,000. Agent Smith represents a different insurer and proposes replacing the policy with a new universal life policy with a $500,000 death benefit and a projected premium of $5,000 per year. Smith provides a replacement notice and a comparison of the policies. However, Smith does not disclose that the new policy has a 15-year surrender charge period and that the projected premium is not guaranteed. Mrs. Jones is confused but trusts Smith.
1. What ethical and regulatory issues does this replacement raise?
Read the worked answer
The replacement raises several issues: 1) Suitability: The new policy may not be suitable for a 65-year-old due to the long surrender charge period and higher premium. 2) Disclosure: Smith must fully disclose all material facts, including surrender charges and non-guaranteed elements. Failure to do so is a violation of replacement regulations and unethical. 3) Twisting: Smith may be guilty of twisting if he misrepresented the existing policy to induce replacement. 4) The replacement notice must be provided, and the existing insurer must be notified. Smith should ensure Mrs. Jones understands the consequences, including loss of cash value and new contestability period. He should also consider whether the increased death benefit is necessary and affordable.
2. What should Mrs. Jones consider before replacing her policy?
Read the worked answer
Mrs. Jones should consider: 1) The cost of surrendering her existing policy, including surrender charges (if any) and loss of accumulated cash value. 2) The new policy's surrender charges and how long they last. 3) The new premium is higher and may increase in the future if not guaranteed. 4) She will have a new contestability period and suicide clause. 5) The new policy's death benefit is higher, but does she need it? 6) She should compare guaranteed values and ask for illustrations. 7) She should consult a trusted advisor or the state insurance department. 8) She should not be pressured into a quick decision.