Library on Wheels Evidence
In Barangay Malinis, the youth council launched a 'library on wheels' in January. Volunteers load 300 books into a borrowed tricycle and visit three puroks every Saturday. After six months, the council reports that 1,200 children borrowed books, but only 180 returned them on time. The council president says the program is a success because 'children are reading more than before.' A teacher notes that many borrowed books were returned late, damaged, or not returned at all. The council has no baseline data on how many children read before January. It also spent 40% of its annual budget on fuel and repairs, leaving little for new titles. At the next assembly, residents will decide whether to continue the program, revise it, or stop it.
1. What is the strongest inference about the president's claim that the program is a success? Support your answer with details from the passage.
Read the worked answer
The president's claim is not well supported. The 1,200 borrowers show that children used the service, but 'reading more than before' requires baseline data, and the passage says the council has none. The return data weaken the success claim: only 180 of 1,200 borrowings were returned on time (15%), and the teacher says many were late, damaged, or never returned. The budget detail also shows a cost problem: 40% of the annual budget went to fuel and repairs. The strongest inference is that the program has high participation but weak evidence of improved reading and serious management issues; 'success' is an overstatement.
2. If residents want to keep the program, which decision fits the evidence best: continue unchanged, revise, or stop? Explain using the passage.
Read the worked answer
Revise rather than continue as is or stop. Stopping would discard real demand: 1,200 children borrowed books in six months. Continuing unchanged would repeat the low return rate and budget strain. A revision could require a simple borrower card or parent contact, set up a weekly return checkpoint, reduce trips to two puroks per Saturday to save fuel, and ask for book donations or a business partner for new titles. These changes address the two specific problems in the passage-poor returns and 40% spending on fuel and repairs-while keeping the service.
3. Identify one unstated assumption in the teacher's criticism and explain why it matters for the council's decision.
Read the worked answer
The teacher assumes that late, damaged, or unreturned books prove children are not reading or that the program is failing. But the passage gives no information about why returns failed: there may be no drop-off point, no reminder system, or books may be shared among siblings. The criticism is valid as a warning about accountability, but it does not by itself show that reading did not increase. The council should collect return-reason data before using the teacher's point to end the program.