Five and a Half Hours Without Power in a School Canteen Cold Room
At a 240-student school canteen, the cold room log shows 3 degrees Celsius at 10:00 pm. The area's scheduled power cut starts at 11:00 pm; the backup generator fails to start at 1:00 am and no one notices until the cook arrives at 6:30 am. The cold room thermometer then reads 12 degrees Celsius and the room smells faintly sour. Doors were opened twice overnight by the security guard. Ambient night temperature was 33 degrees Celsius. Stock inside: 40 kg raw chicken, 25 kg plain yoghurt, 15 kg cooked rice prepared the previous afternoon, 30 kg whole vegetables, 10 kg opened mayonnaise and 8 kg sealed butter. There is no data logger, only twice-daily manual checks, and the last entry is 10:00 pm. School opens at 8:00 am; lunch service is at 12:30 pm.
1. Which items should be kept and which discarded? Show your reasoning item by item.
Read the worked answer
Judge each item by whether it gets a kill step, and how long it was plausibly above 5 degrees Celsius. With no logger, assume the worst case: 1:00 am to 6:30 am is five and a half hours in a 33 degree ambient room that reached 12 degrees Celsius.
- Cooked rice (15 kg) - discard. Classic Bacillus cereus risk; the toxin is heat-stable, so reheating does not make it safe. It was also a day old before the outage.
- Yoghurt (25 kg) - discard. Ready to eat, no kill step, and the sour smell suggests it is already spoiling.
- Opened mayonnaise (10 kg) - discard. Ready to eat, no kill step, and emulsion products are poor candidates for benefit of the doubt.
- Raw chicken (40 kg) - discard. Cooking lowers the risk, but five and a half unverified hours plus door openings is too much to sign off; numbers may have grown and handling cross-contamination risk rises. An emergency 'cook immediately to 75 degrees Celsius core and use in the same service' route exists, but in a school the defensible decision is discard.
- Whole vegetables (30 kg) - keep. Intact skins, low-risk food, to be washed and mostly cooked. Discard cut or damaged pieces.
- Sealed butter (8 kg) - keep. High fat, low moisture, no melting or rancidity; 12 degrees Celsius for a few hours is not a safety issue.
2. What is missing from the records, and how should the manager document the decision?
Read the worked answer
The file has a five-hour hole, and the manager must write the gap down rather than paper over it.
- What is missing: no continuous temperature record, no alarm on the cold room or generator, no night check, and no record of how long the doors stood open. The 10:00 pm entry proves nothing about 1:00 to 6:30 am.
- Write an incident report the same morning: time the supply failed, time the generator failed, time the reading was taken, the 12 degree reading, door-opening times, ambient temperature, and a list of every item with weight and the keep or discard decision, signed and countersigned by the head teacher or manager.
- State the assumption explicitly: product assumed above 5 degrees Celsius from approximately 01:00 to 06:30. An honest worst case is defensible; an invented log is a falsification and destroys credibility.
- Retain evidence: photograph the thermometer, the log and the discarded stock, and keep disposal records with weights.
- Do not serve anything from the affected stock while the decision is being made, and inform the school authorities before lunch, not after.
3. What preventive controls would you require so that the next outage does not become another mass discard?
Read the worked answer
Fix the cause, not just the stock.
- Monitoring with alarms: a data logger with a high-temperature alarm and battery backup, plus a generator failure alarm that is audible or sends a message; a night check by security with one simple recorded reading.
- Written procedure: what to do when power fails - keep doors closed, do not open the room for stock checks, move high-risk items into insulated boxes with gel packs, call the named responsible person, record everything.
- Stock discipline: keep cooked rice and other high-risk items to a one-day buffer. The 15 kg of cooked rice was already a day old before the outage, which turned a power cut into a disposal.
- Menu and supplier planning: for outage-prone areas, plan a cold-room-light menu or buy in from a licensed supplier rather than improvising on the day.
- Training and testing: one drill per term for canteen staff, and a monthly generator test under load with a signed record.
- Review test: after any discard, ask whether two different managers would make the same decision. If not, the procedure needs to be clearer.