15-Year-Old With Moderate Depression, Passive Suicidal Ideation, and a Request for Secrecy
Jade is 15 years 7 months old, a sophomore, brought by her mother for a sports physical. Alone, she says she has felt "empty" for 3 months, quit soccer, sleeps about 5 hours, and has dropped from A/B to C grades. Her PHQ-A score is 17; on item 9 she endorses "thoughts that you would be better off dead" a few days in the past two weeks. She denies plan, intent, prior attempts, or firearm access; her mother keeps all medications locked. There is no mania, no substance use, no psychosis. Her best friend knows and checks on her. Jade says, "Please don't tell my mom. She'll freak out and pull me out of school." Her mother is in the waiting room expecting only a physical.
1. How do you handle confidentiality, and exactly what do you tell the mother?
Read the worked answer
Set limits before taking the history, not after. At the start of any private adolescent interview, state: what is shared stays private unless there is risk of harm to self or others, abuse, or a medical emergency. Jade was told this, so the promise she is asking for was never made.
Negotiate disclosure rather than announce it. Tell Jade that depression of this severity and item-9 endorsement cannot be managed secretly, and offer to tell her mother with Jade in the room, framing it as safety and treatment rather than punishment. This preserves the alliance, which is the main predictor of her staying in care.
Disclose to the mother: the diagnosis, the safety concern, the need for means restriction and supervision, the treatment plan, and warning signs. Do not disclose unrelated content she did not consent to (for example, sexual history) unless it bears on safety.
Document what was disclosed, why, and Jade's response. Note that the mother's anxiety is itself a treatment target; a catastrophizing parent may pull her from school or from care, so rehearse the conversation with her.
2. Can she go home today? Lay out your safety assessment and disposition reasoning.
Read the worked answer
Risk formulation, not just a score. PHQ-A 17 is moderate-severe. Item 9 at "a few days" without plan, intent, or preparation is passive ideation. Protective factors are substantial: she disclosed voluntarily, has a monitoring friend, no firearm access, medications locked, no substance use, no prior attempt.
Static risk factors to weigh against that: prior attempt is the strongest predictor and is absent here, but female sex, depression severity, and social withdrawal (quitting soccer) raise baseline risk.
Disposition: she can go home today if all of the following hold - no plan or intent, lethal means secured, an adult who will supervise and can be reached, a written safety plan she helped create, and a follow-up appointment within 1-2 weeks. If any of these fail, or if intent emerges during the interview, she needs emergency evaluation the same day.
Safety plan elements: warning signs she recognizes, coping strategies, people and places that distract her, her friend and mother as contacts, professional and crisis numbers (988), and environmental safety - no access to medications or firearms.
Say explicitly to both: "If you have thoughts of acting, tell an adult and call 988 or go to the emergency department." Do not rely on a no-suicide contract; it has no evidence.
3. Do you start an SSRI today? Give the agent, dose, monitoring schedule, and how you discuss the boxed warning.
Read the worked answer
Yes - moderate-severe depression with functional decline warrants medication alongside psychotherapy. Withholding an SSRI because of the boxed warning leaves a treatable illness untreated; the correct response is closer monitoring.
Agent and dose: fluoxetine is the SSRI with an FDA-approved pediatric depression indication from age 8; escitalopram is approved from age 12. Start fluoxetine 10 mg daily for 1-2 weeks, then 20 mg. Do not exceed 20 mg in an adolescent without specialist input.
Monitoring schedule: weekly contact for the first 4 weeks, then every 2 weeks for 4 weeks, then at 6 and 12 weeks - in person or by phone, with a structured check of suicidal ideation, activation, akathisia, and sleep.
Explain the boxed warning plainly: "In the first weeks, a small number of young people become more agitated or have more suicidal thoughts before they improve. That is why we talk every week and why your mother is watching for changes. Call us the same day if that happens." Also warn about activation, avoid abrupt discontinuation, and recommend concurrent CBT - combined treatment outperforms either alone in adolescents.