Two Beers, Cold Medicine, and a Mountain Road
Your 19-year-old friend has had two 12-ounce beers over about two hours at a birthday party. He also took a cold medicine earlier in the evening; the label warns of drowsiness. He weighs about 130 pounds. It is 1 a.m., and the drive home is 15 minutes on a dark, winding mountain road - the kind with tight curves and no streetlights. He says he feels completely normal and that the cold medicine 'wore off hours ago.' Two other friends say he seems fine and tell him to drive carefully. He picks up his keys.
1. Should he drive? Identify every factor that raises the risk.
Read the worked answer
No. Each factor alone is a reason to find another ride; together they are decisive.
- Age: at 19 he is under the 21 threshold, and Puerto Rico applies a near-zero standard (0.02%) for underage drivers. Any measurable alcohol is a violation, and a small, inexperienced drinker reaches that range easily on two beers.
- Body weight and timing: 130 pounds with two beers in two hours puts him in the range where reaction time, night vision and divided attention are already degraded, even if he is under the adult per-se limit.
- Drug interaction: sedating antihistamines and alcohol depress the central nervous system additively. 'It wore off hours ago' is his guess, not a measurement.
- Conditions: 1 a.m. adds fatigue, and an unlit winding road demands the exact skills - tracking a curve, spotting hazards - that alcohol and sedation attack first.
2. What do you do about the keys, and how do you answer the friends who say he seems fine?
Read the worked answer
Take the keys and offer a concrete alternative - ride, taxi/rideshare, sober friend, or stay over.
- 'He seems fine' is a test of how he talks and walks while sitting still, not of reaction time, glare recovery, or the ability to divide attention between a curve and an oncoming car. Those are the skills that fail first and matter most.
- The fact that he feels normal is itself expected: impairment blunts the judgment used to assess impairment. The person least able to judge is the one who has been drinking.
- 'Drive carefully' is not a control. Most fatal crashes happen at night on rural roads, exactly this drive, and 'I'll go slow' does not restore braking judgment on a wet curve.
- A short argument in a parking lot is a far better outcome than a crash; make the alternative easy and immediate rather than moralizing.
3. If a police officer later stops him and asks for a breath test, what follows from a refusal?
Read the worked answer
Refusing does not avoid the case - it adds a separate license problem.
- Holding a Puerto Rico license means consenting in advance to chemical testing when an officer has reasonable grounds. Refusing triggers its own administrative suspension and penalties, independent of whether the DUI charge ultimately succeeds.
- A refusal can also be used against the driver in the DUI proceeding, and it does not prevent arrest - the officer may proceed on driving behavior and field sobriety observations.
- The point for the case: the only decision that actually protects him was made in the parking lot. Once the keys are in the ignition, every later option is worse.