Source Analysis of the Ara Pacis and Res Gestae
In a Roman civilization seminar, a student submits a source-analysis paragraph: "The Ara Pacis was dedicated in 9 BCE to celebrate Augustus's conquest of Britain. Its panels show only mythological scenes, so it tells us nothing about Augustan political ideology. Therefore the Res Gestae is a more reliable source because Augustus wrote it himself." The class has read about the monument's dedication, its location in the Campus Martius, the processional frieze with Augustus and family members, and the Tellus panel. The seminar has 18 students and 50 minutes; the instructor plans a 10-minute peer review before a whole-class discussion. The goal is to use the paragraph to teach evidence evaluation rather than simply correct it.
1. Identify the factual and evidentiary errors in the paragraph.
Read the worked answer
The paragraph contains at least three errors. First, Britain was not conquered under Augustus; the Claudian invasion began in 43 CE, long after the Ara Pacis was dedicated in 9 BCE. The monument is associated with Augustus's return from campaigns in Gaul and Spain and with the theme of peace, not a British triumph. Second, the panels are not "only mythological." They include mythological or legendary panels such as Aeneas and Romulus, but also the processional frieze with Augustus, family members, and magistrates, plus the Tellus/vegetal panel celebrating fertility and abundance. Third, "Augustus wrote it himself" does not make the Res Gestae neutral; it is an official autobiographical summary of achievements and honors, designed for public display. The student has confused authorship with reliability and has treated propaganda as disqualifying rather than as evidence of self-presentation.
2. How can the Ara Pacis be used as evidence for Augustan ideology despite being a commissioned monument?
Read the worked answer
A commissioned monument does not give neutral facts, but it does provide evidence of how the regime wanted to be seen. The processional frieze places Augustus and his family within a public ritual, emphasizing continuity, dynasty, and civic order. The Tellus panel links peace with agricultural abundance and fertility, a central Augustan theme after civil war. The Aeneas panel connects the regime to Trojan foundation and pietas, while Romulus evokes Rome's origins and military virtue. The Campus Martius location places the monument in a public, triumphal landscape. Limits matter: the monument is damaged and reconstructed, its viewing audience is difficult to recover, and it represents elite and imperial perspectives. The instructor should push the student from "propaganda therefore useless" to "propaganda therefore evidence of ideological self-fashioning, with limits."
3. What comparison with the Res Gestae would sharpen the analysis?
Read the worked answer
The Res Gestae and the Ara Pacis are both official Augustan texts, but in different media. The Res Gestae lists achievements, offices, expenditures, and honors in a first-person voice, emphasizing consensus, pietas, and generosity. The Ara Pacis communicates through visual allegory and ritual procession, emphasizing peace, fertility, family, and foundation. Comparing them would show that "reliable" is the wrong question: neither is a neutral chronicle, and each reveals what the regime chose to publicize and omit. A sharper analysis would ask what themes recur in both-peace, piety, family, public benefaction-and what each medium can and cannot show. The Res Gestae is not more reliable simply because Augustus wrote it; it is a different kind of official source with its own rhetorical aims.