Stage III grade C periodontitis with poorly controlled diabetes and smoking
A 54-year-old man attends a new patient examination. He smokes 20 cigarettes daily and has type 2 diabetes diagnosed 8 years ago; his most recent HbA1c is 9.2%. He reports bleeding gums and intermittent swelling of the lower left first molar. Examination shows generalized marginal erythema, plaque and calculus, probing depths of 6–8 mm on the molars and 4–5 mm elsewhere, 4 mm recession on the lower incisors, and mobility II on the lower left first molar. A panoramic radiograph shows 50–60% horizontal bone loss generally and a vertical defect on the mesial of the lower left second molar. The lower left first molar has a 9-mm pocket, furcation involvement, and no opposing tooth. He asks whether the tooth can be saved and whether antibiotics will 'cure' the infection. He has not had periodontal treatment before.
1. Assign a periodontal stage and grade, and justify each with the data provided.
Read the worked answer
Stage III, generalized, grade C. Stage is based on severity and complexity: interdental clinical attachment loss is at least 5 mm in several areas, radiographic bone loss extends to the middle third of the roots, and the lower left first molar has a 9-mm pocket with furcation involvement and mobility II. There is no reported tooth loss from periodontitis, so stage IV is not established, but the vertical defect and mobility place it at the severe end of stage III. Grade reflects progression risk: smoking 20 cigarettes/day is ≥10/day, and HbA1c 9.2% is ≥7.0%, both consistent with grade C. The vertical defect on the lower left second molar also suggests rapid progression. The generalized pattern and poor metabolic control mean the patient is at high risk of further attachment loss and should be managed with risk-factor control, not just scaling.
2. Outline the initial therapy sequence and explain your recommendation for the lower left first molar and for systemic antibiotics.
Read the worked answer
Begin with cause-related therapy: oral hygiene instruction, professional mechanical plaque removal, and supragingival scaling, then subgingival instrumentation of all pockets. Provide smoking cessation advice and refer to a diabetes team; aim for HbA1c review. Do not prescribe routine systemic antibiotics for periodontitis; they are an adjunct, not a cure, and are best reserved for specific situations such as grade C disease with generalized deep pockets after full-mouth instrumentation, or acute infection. If used, amoxicillin with metronidazole is a common regimen, but only after discussing benefits and risks. For the lower left first molar, the 9-mm pocket, furcation involvement, mobility II, and absence of an opposing tooth give a poor long-term prognosis. Explain that extraction may be more predictable than heroic treatment, but make the decision with the patient after initial therapy and re-evaluation; if retained, it needs careful debridement and possibly furcation surgery, which has a guarded outcome. Extract only after controlling acute infection and considering his diabetes.
3. What re-evaluation interval and maintenance plan would you use, and when would you refer?
Read the worked answer
Re-evaluate 6–8 weeks after completing subgingival instrumentation. At that visit, reassess probing depths, bleeding on probing, plaque scores, mobility, and the medical risk factors. Residual pockets ≥5 mm with bleeding, especially in the molar region, indicate persistent inflammation and a need for further therapy. Refer for periodontal surgery or regenerative assessment if residual deep vertical defects remain, if furcation involvement is not manageable, or if the patient's response is poor despite good plaque control. Arrange supportive periodontal therapy at 3-month intervals initially, because grade C disease and diabetes increase recurrence risk. Monitor HbA1c and smoking status at each visit; if HbA1c remains above 8% or he continues to smoke, the prognosis is guarded and implant placement should be avoided. Coordinate with his physician and reinforce that antibiotics alone will not cure periodontitis.