The Missing Tool and the Shift Log
At 06:45, during apparatus checkout, you find that a forcible-entry set (a Halligan-style bar and a flat-head axe) is missing from its bracket on Engine 2. The previous shift's log shows the tool was checked and present at 22:00 the night before. A newer firefighter on your crew, Reyes, mentions he 'borrowed something like that' to help a neighbor pry open a shed door after his shift and 'thinks he put it back.' The company officer is not yet on duty. A call could drop at any time.
1. What are your immediate actions before the officer arrives, and in what order?
Read the worked answer
- Make the apparatus safe and honest: note the missing tool on the checkout sheet and confirm the bracket is empty - do not sign off a complete checkout.
- Restore capability first: replace the missing set from spare stock or borrow from another company so Engine 2 is fully equipped before any call. A missing forcible-entry tool is a life-safety gap.
- Get the facts from Reyes without interrogation: ask specifically what he took, when, and where it is now. Record his account verbatim.
- Notify the company officer as soon as practicable and before end of shift - this is not yours to quietly resolve.
Order matters: capability restored before paperwork, but the missing-tool fact documented immediately so it cannot be mistaken for a later loss.
2. Reyes asks you to 'not make it a big deal' since he returned it. How do you handle that?
Read the worked answer
Be clear and kind: 'I'm not out to get you, but I can't sit on it. A missing tool on the rig is a safety issue, and the log has to be accurate.' Explain that the problem is not the favor to a neighbor - it is taking company equipment off the apparatus without accounting for it, which left the crew short on a forcible-entry capability. Tell him you will report what he told you accurately, including that he returned it, and encourage him to tell the officer himself first. Do not promise to conceal it, and do not exaggerate it. Integrity here means accurate reporting, not punishment.
3. The officer arrives and asks whether the tool was present at shift change. What do you say?
Read the worked answer
State exactly what you know: the tool was not on the bracket at 06:45; the prior log recorded it present at 22:00; Reyes reported borrowing it after his shift and believes he returned it; the set has since been replaced/accounted for. Do not speculate about whether it was present at the exact moment of shift change - say what the records and witnesses show and flag the gap. If asked for a recommendation, suggest a documented inventory reconciliation and a reminder about equipment accountability. The tested behavior is precise, non-defensive honesty under pressure to give a simple yes/no.