Deductible, Coinsurance, Out-of-Pocket Maximum, and a Surprise Bill
A 45-year-old member has an individual major medical plan with a $2,500 in-network deductible, 80/20 coinsurance, a $7,000 in-network out-of-pocket maximum, and $30 office-visit copays. The plan has no out-of-network benefits except emergencies. She has an in-network hospital surgery billed at $42,000, an in-network surgeon bill of $8,000, and four in-network office visits. An out-of-network assistant surgeon bills $3,000 separately. The plan denies a preoperative MRI as not medically necessary; her physician disagrees. Assume all amounts are allowed charges unless stated and that copays count toward the out-of-pocket maximum.
1. Calculate her out-of-pocket responsibility for the in-network claims.
Read the worked answer
Total in-network allowed charges: $42,000 + $8,000 = $50,000. Apply the $2,500 deductible, leaving $47,500. Her 20% coinsurance would be $9,500. Deductible plus coinsurance would be $12,000, which exceeds the $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum.
The out-of-pocket maximum caps her cost sharing at $7,000, including the four $30 copays ($120). Her final responsibility is therefore $7,000, consisting of the $2,500 deductible, $4,380 of coinsurance, and $120 of copays. The insurer pays the remaining $43,120 of the allowed charges. Once the $7,000 maximum is reached, the plan pays 100% of covered in-network expenses for the rest of the year.
2. Analyze the out-of-network assistant surgeon bill.
Read the worked answer
The plan has no out-of-network benefits except emergencies, so the $3,000 assistant surgeon charge is not a covered non-emergency benefit. Without protection, the provider could balance bill her for the full $3,000.
However, if the plan is subject to the federal No Surprises Act, an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility may be prohibited from balance billing for certain non-emergency services, and the patient may owe only in-network cost sharing. The member should confirm plan type and whether the hospital and assistant surgeon were scheduled at an in-network facility. She should request a written explanation, ask the plan to process the claim under surprise-billing rules, and appeal any denial. She should not simply pay the $3,000 before exhausting that review.
3. Explain the appeal and external review rights for the MRI denial.
Read the worked answer
The denial is an adverse benefit determination, so the member is entitled to a full and fair internal appeal. She should submit the physician's documentation of medical necessity, the plan's clinical criteria, and any relevant records. If the situation is urgent, she can request an expedited appeal.
After the final internal denial, she generally has the right to independent external review, usually within four months of the final adverse determination, at little or no cost. The external reviewer is independent of the insurer and can reverse the denial. She should also ask whether coverage continues during the appeal and whether the plan failed to follow its own criteria or state law requirements. The file should document dates, requests, and responses.