Mechanical Comprehension: Pick the Right Principle
What is being tested
Everyday physics: levers, pulleys, gears, inclined planes, work and power, pressure, and simple fluid systems. The arithmetic is light; the challenge is recognizing which principle applies.
Core concepts
- Levers: mechanical advantage equals effort arm divided by load arm, both measured from the fulcrum. A longer effort arm means less force but more distance moved. Classes: first (fulcrum between load and effort), second (load between), third (effort between).
- Pulleys: a single fixed pulley changes direction only, with a mechanical advantage of 1. Movable pulleys and systems supported by n rope segments give advantage n, but you pull n times as much rope.
- Gears: meshing gears turn in opposite directions; the larger gear turns slower with more torque. Ratio equals teeth on the driven gear divided by teeth on the driver.
- Work, power, energy: work equals force times distance in the direction of the force; power equals work divided by time. Machines trade force for distance but do not reduce total work, ignoring friction.
- Pressure: pressure equals force divided by area, so a small area produces high pressure, which is why a sharp edge cuts.
- Fluids: in a confined liquid, pressure is transmitted equally in all directions; hydraulic advantage comes from the ratio of piston areas.
Traps
- Confusing force with work: holding a heavy box motionless does no work.
- Assuming a pulley system reduces the work required; it only reduces the force.
- Forgetting that friction always reduces real mechanical advantage.
- Mixing up which gear is the driver in a ratio question.
Worked example
A lever has its fulcrum 2 feet from a 300 pound load, and effort is applied 6 feet from the fulcrum. Mechanical advantage is 6 divided by 2, or 3, so the required effort is 300 divided by 3, or 100 pounds. Check: the effort end moves three times as far as the load.
Rule of thumb
Ask what is being traded. In every simple machine, a smaller force is paid for with a longer distance.