Passenger mustering with a blocked station and non-English speakers
A ro-ro passenger ferry with 1,200 passengers and 80 crew is 2 hours from port when a fire breaks out in the galley. Muster station 3 is filling with smoke and cannot be used; 45 passengers, including 6 wheelchair users, are directed there by a crew member. One lifeboat at that station is under maintenance and cannot be launched. The passengers include a group of 30 who speak no English. The bridge announces 'muster at stations'. The ferry has a valid passenger ship safety certificate.
1. What should the on-scene crew do immediately about the passengers sent to muster station 3?
Read the worked answer
The immediate priority is to stop the flow into the smoke-affected station and redirect the passengers to a safe alternative. The crew member's instruction was understandable under stress but is now wrong. Actions:
- Post a crew member at the approach to station 3 to turn passengers back.
- Redirect the 45 passengers to the nearest safe muster station with capacity, using stairways-not lifts-and keeping them clear of the fire zone.
- Close fire doors and boundary doors on the route to contain smoke.
- For the 6 wheelchair users, assign at least two crew per wheelchair and use evacuation chairs or designated accessible routes; do not use escalators or lifts.
- Report the redirected numbers to the bridge so the passenger accounting is corrected.
Reasoning: Mustering into a smoke-filled space creates a second casualty stream and undermines the head count. The crew must fix the routing first, then account for the passengers at the new station.
2. How should the crew account for the passengers and handle the language barrier and the unavailable lifeboat?
Read the worked answer
Accounting must be active, not assumed. The crew should:
- Take a head count at the new station against the passenger list or cabin list.
- Use muster cards, pictograms, and multilingual recorded announcements for the 30 non-English speakers; assign crew who share their language or use gesture and demonstration.
- Check the 6 wheelchair users are logged at the correct station and that their assistants are identified.
The unavailable lifeboat changes the capacity calculation. The station's remaining boats and liferafts must be checked for sufficient capacity for the redirected passengers. If capacity is short, redistribute passengers to adjacent stations before any abandon-ship order. The valid passenger ship safety certificate does not mean the current configuration is usable; the crew must adapt to the actual failed boat and the closed station. If a passenger refuses to move, do not physically force them unless immediate danger requires it; record the refusal, assign a crew member to stay with them, and inform the bridge.
3. What should the bridge announce and what should the master consider before any abandon-ship decision?
Read the worked answer
The bridge announcement should be short, calm, and directive: state that station 3 is closed, name the alternative station, and tell passengers to follow crew. Repeat it in the languages represented on board and use pictograms or crew at stairways.
Before abandoning, the master should consider:
- Whether the fire is contained and the vessel can reach port in 2 hours.
- Whether the alternative muster stations and remaining lifeboats can hold all persons.
- Whether the smoke is spreading into accommodation or stairways.
- Whether the weather and sea state make evacuation more dangerous than staying aboard.
Reasoning: Abandoning a ferry with 1,200 passengers is a last resort, especially with a nearby port. The master should prepare for evacuation-brief boat crews, check capacity, account for all persons-but order it only if the vessel is in grave and imminent danger. The blocked station and missing boat are planning problems, not by themselves grounds to abandon.