The Ashes and the Second Family
A man died and was cremated eight months ago. His widow arranged the funeral and collected the ashes. She now asks the funeral director to inter the ashes in her garden and provide a small marker. While preparing, the funeral director is contacted by the man's adult daughter from a previous marriage. She says her father had told her he wanted his ashes scattered on a hill where he walked, and she produces a text message from him saying so. The widow says the text was sent in jest and that she has the ashes in her possession. The daughter is threatening to complain and to 'go to the crematorium'. The garden is a rented property and the tenancy agreement is silent on burial of ashes.
1. Who has the right to decide what happens to the ashes, and how should the funeral director proceed?
Read the worked answer
- The ashes are not 'property' in the ordinary sense, but the person who arranged the cremation generally has the authority to decide their disposal. Here that is the widow, who collected them.
- The text message is evidence of the deceased's wishes, not a legal instruction. It should be recorded and considered, but it does not transfer authority to the daughter.
- The funeral director should not hand the ashes to the daughter or act on her instructions without the widow's agreement.
- Proceed carefully: confirm in writing what the widow wants, explain that the daughter has raised an objection, and ask the widow whether she wishes to discuss it with the daughter. Offer to facilitate a conversation.
- Do not take sides or disclose the daughter's messages without consent.
- Signpost the daughter to independent advice if she wishes to pursue it; the funeral director is not the decision-maker.
- Record everything, including the text message and the widow's response.
- Consider the tenancy issue for the garden interment separately.
2. What practical and legal issues arise from interring ashes in a rented garden?
Read the worked answer
- Tenancy: the agreement is silent, so the funeral director should advise the widow to obtain the landlord's written consent. A future landlord or tenant may not wish to maintain a grave, and the family could lose access if they move.
- Deed of dedication or record: keep a written record of the location and depth, and consider whether a faculty or local authority rule applies (usually not for a private garden, but check).
- Marker: a small marker is usually acceptable, but planning or listed-building consent may apply in some settings.
- Environmental and practical: depth, soil, drainage, and distance from water courses and boundaries; some councils have guidance.
- Future sale of the property: the family should understand that a garden grave can complicate a sale and may not be protected.
- Alternatives: offer interment in a churchyard or cemetery, or scattering at the hill the daughter describes, as options to discuss.
- Document the decision and the advice given, so the firm is not later blamed if the tenancy ends.