The Student Who Won't Wear the Seatbelt
Before a lesson, a 16-year-old student gets in the driver's seat but refuses to buckle the seatbelt, saying it's uncomfortable and "nothing's going to happen in a parking lot." Your school's policy requires seatbelts for all occupants at all times, and state law requires belt use. The student's parent is not present. The student is otherwise cooperative and has 15 hours of driving. You have a 90-minute lesson scheduled.
1. What do you do, and what is your reasoning?
Read the worked answer
Do not start the lesson. The belt requirement is non-negotiable: it's both school policy and law, and an instructor who drives without enforcing it models unsafe behavior and exposes the student, themselves, and the school to liability. Calmly explain the rule, why it exists (belts save lives even at low speeds and in parking lots), and that the lesson cannot proceed unbuckled. Offer a brief pause to let the student decide. If they still refuse, end or reschedule the lesson and notify the parent/guardian per policy. The reasoning: safety policy and law override lesson convenience, and consistency now teaches the student that safety rules are not negotiable.
2. How do you handle the administrative follow-up?
Read the worked answer
Document the refusal, the policy cited, your response, and the outcome (lesson not conducted or rescheduled) factually. Notify the parent/guardian as required and note the conversation. This protects the school if the family disputes a charge or the missed lesson, and it creates a record if the behavior recurs. Avoid editorializing about the student; stick to observable facts and policy references.