Own-Occupation, Residual Benefits, and Offsets for a Partially Disabled Dentist
Priya is 56 and a practicing dentist earning $220,000 a year, roughly $18,300 a month. Her individually owned disability policy pays $8,000 a month after a 90-day elimination period, with an own-occupation definition for 24 months that then becomes any-occupation, and a residual benefit that pays proportionally when her income loss is at least 20%. She pays the premium with personal funds. Her practice also provides group long-term disability paying 60% of base salary to a $6,000 monthly maximum, with the employer paying the premium and the plan offsetting other income benefits. A nerve injury in her dominant hand ends her surgical work. After the elimination period she works three days a week doing exams and consulting, earning $9,200 a month.
1. How much does each coverage pay while she works part-time, and how do the policies interact?
Read the worked answer
Start with the income loss. Prior earnings $18,300; current earnings $9,200. Loss = $9,100, or about 50% of pre-disability income. That comfortably exceeds the 20% threshold, so the residual benefit is triggered.
Individual policy - proportional residual. The policy pays the benefit in proportion to lost income: 50% of $8,000 = $4,000 a month. Many residual provisions also guarantee a minimum benefit (commonly 50% of the monthly benefit) once the loss threshold is crossed, which would raise the payment to $4,000 here anyway. Because she has no other-income offset rider on the individual contract, the group benefit does not reduce this payment.
Group LTD - offset applies. The group plan computes 60% of base ($11,000) but caps at $6,000, then subtracts other income benefits, which typically include the individual disability benefit. $6,000 − $4,000 = $2,000 a month, subject to an overall cap (often 70% of pre-disability earnings, about $12,800 here) - the combined $6,000 is well under that cap.
Total: about $6,000 a month, $4,000 tax-free from the individual policy and $2,000 taxable from the group plan. This is exactly why the individual policy was worth buying: without it the group plan would pay $6,000, and with it the total is still $6,000 - but the tax character is far better and the individual contract is portable if she leaves the practice.
Also check Washington Paid Family and Medical Leave. Her own serious health condition may qualify for state medical leave benefits. The group plan likely offsets that wage-replacement benefit; the individual policy generally does not unless it has an other-income rider.
2. Explain the tax treatment of the two benefit streams and identify any trap in how the individual premium was paid.
Read the worked answer
Group LTD - taxable. The employer paid the premium and did not include it in her income, so the benefits are ordinary income to Priya. She should expect a 1099 and should plan withholding or estimated payments; $2,000 a month of taxable benefit is not the same as $2,000 of take-home pay.
Individually owned policy - tax-free. Premiums were paid with after-tax dollars, so the $4,000 monthly benefit is received free of income tax. That is the single biggest structural reason to own personal disability coverage alongside a group plan.
The trap: if the practice had paid the individual policy premium through the business (for example, the corporation pays the premium and deducts it), the benefit stream would become taxable, and if the owner had deducted the premiums, the IRS position is that the benefits can be taxed. Paying personally - or using a properly structured arrangement where premiums are not deducted - preserves the tax-free benefit. Mixing the two years later, or letting the practice reimburse premium without a documented plan, can retroactively taint the character of the benefit.
One more point: benefits paid under a policy that has been in force for a long time are still tax-free; there is no time limit. The relevant question is always who paid the premium and whether it was deducted.
3. What changes at month 24, and what happens if she takes a full-time teaching position at the dental school paying $110,000?
Read the worked answer
At month 24 the definition of total disability changes. During the first 24 months, 'own occupation' means she is disabled if she cannot perform the material duties of a dentist. After that, the test becomes whether she can perform the material duties of any occupation for which she is reasonably fitted by education, training, and experience.
Residual benefits do not automatically stop at month 24. The residual provision is driven by income loss, not by the total-disability definition. If she continues part-time at $9,200 a month with a 50% loss, the residual payment continues.
If she takes the $110,000 teaching job: annualized that is about $9,167 a month, essentially the same 50% income loss, so on these numbers the residual benefit continues at roughly $4,000 a month. The important judgment is that the any-occupation test does not mean 'you can work, so benefits end' - it means the insurer asks whether she can perform the material duties of a reasonably related occupation. Teaching dental students at a reduced salary does not restore her pre-disability earnings, so the income-loss trigger is still met.
Where it would end: if she replaced enough income (typically 80–100% of pre-disability earnings, depending on the policy) the residual benefit would stop, and if she became able to perform the material duties of a reasonably fitted occupation at comparable pay, a total-disability claim would fail. She should also confirm whether the new employer's benefits or state PFML payments are offsettable - the group plan likely offsets them; her individual policy, absent an other-income rider, does not.