Hurricane Deductible, Special Limits, and a Home Business
The Whitakers own an HO-3 with Coverage A of $400,000 on a house worth $420,000, Coverage B of $40,000, Coverage C of $200,000, a $2,000 all-perils deductible, a 5% hurricane deductible, and no endorsements. During a named hurricane, a falling oak opened the roof over the den and rain poured in for two days before tarps arrived. Damage: $260,000 to the dwelling, $30,000 to personal property in the den, and $900 of spoiled food from the outage. Their daughter, who lives at home, lost $9,000 of computers and a $3,000 printer she uses for her graphic-design business, all kept in the den. Removing the fallen tree cost $4,500. The Whitakers filed one claim covering all of it.
1. Which deductible applies, and how much does the policy pay for the dwelling and the personal property?
Read the worked answer
The percentage hurricane deductible controls. A named hurricane triggered it, and the percentage is computed on the Coverage A limit, not on the loss: 5% × $400,000 = $20,000. The $2,000 all-perils deductible does not apply to this loss.
It applies once per occurrence, across coverages. The rain damage is part of the hurricane loss - the roof opening was made by the windstorm, so that damage does not get its own $2,000 deductible. Charging the hurricane deductible to Coverage A and the all-perils deductible to Coverage C would be a double deductible and an error.
- Dwelling: $260,000 − $20,000 = $240,000 (within the $400,000 limit)
- Personal property: $30,000 payable in full (within the $200,000 limit), deductible already exhausted
- Total, before special limits: $270,000
Note the dwelling is underinsured relative to replacement cost; the policy still pays the limit, but the Whitakers will absorb the shortfall themselves. Recommend an inflation-guard review at renewal.
2. Address the $900 of spoiled food, the $12,000 of business equipment, and the $4,500 tree removal.
Read the worked answer
Spoiled food - $500. Coverage C carries a special limit for food spoilage (commonly $500). The power failure was caused by the hurricane, a covered peril, so the off-premises power-failure exclusion does not defeat the claim; the limit is simply low.
Business equipment - $2,500. The HO-3 special limit for property used primarily for business purposes is $2,500 on the residence premises ($500 off premises). A $12,000 loss therefore pays $2,500. Two further points: the electronic data itself is excluded or tightly sublimited, so only the hardware has value; and the daughter's real solution is a businessowners policy or a home-business endorsement, not the homeowners form.
Tree removal - $1,000. The policy pays to remove a tree that has damaged covered property, up to $1,000 per tree and $5,000 in total. The oak struck the dwelling, so $1,000 of the $4,500 is payable; the balance is the insured's. Had the tree fallen in the yard without hitting a structure, removal generally would not be covered at all except for limited cost to clear a driveway or handicap ramp.
All three amounts are additive because the single deductible was already absorbed by the hurricane loss.
3. The daughter's client threatens to sue because a design file was destroyed and a deadline was missed. Will the HO-3 defend her?
Read the worked answer
No. Coverage E excludes bodily injury and property damage arising out of an insured's business activities. The daughter's graphic-design work is a business, conducted at home, and the claim grows directly out of it.
Supporting obstacles even if the business exclusion were absent:
- Coverage E responds to "property damage" as defined; a lost file and a missed deadline are largely economic loss, and damage to property in the insured's care, custody or control is excluded.
- The form's exclusions for the insured's product or work would also be pointed at any redone design work.
The defense obligation follows the coverage decision: no coverage means no duty to defend this claim. The right product is a professional liability/E&O policy or a BOP with professional services coverage, plus a business-property endorsement for the equipment and a data-restoration sublimit. Advising the family that "the homeowners will handle it" is the mistake to avoid.